When PS is appropriate
Example 4 — Electronics — same setup, but distribution is routine
Annex II Ch.II · Example 4 · ¶16–19 · Electronics MNE
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same as Example 3, except that Company B's marketing is limited and does not significantly enhance the brand, and its distribution does not provide a competitive advantage. Success rests on Company A's product and price. Does profit split still fit?
The parties
Company A
Design · development · manufacturing · drives successfinished products
Company B
Limited marketing · routine distribution · feedback relayWhat happens
- Company A designs, develops and manufactures the new product line.
- Company A sells to Company B.
- Company B performs limited marketing that does not significantly enhance goodwill or reputation.
- Company B operates a simple customer feedback relay — not a unique and valuable contribution.
- Distribution does not provide a particular source of competitive advantage; success depends on the product's technical specs, design and price.
Analysis
Company A bears all the meaningful risks (design, development, manufacturing). Company B's marketing and distribution risks aren't economically significant, and its work isn't unique or valuable.
Is profit split still the right method?
OECD analysis · One-sided method on Company B
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 4 (¶19), where Company B does not make any unique and valuable contribution and its assumed risks are not economically significant, the transactional profit split is unlikely to be the most appropriate method. The arm's length compensation for Company B can be reliably benchmarked using a one-sided method (e.g. TNMM on Company B). Profit split is not a default for any two-party intra-group flow.
Key takeaway
Profit split is reserved for cases where one-sided methods fail. If one party's contribution can be benchmarked reliably, that's the tested party — even if the counterparty has substantial value drivers.
Related: ¶2.127 (when PS is not appropriate) · Example 3 (mirror — when distribution IS unique)