When PS is appropriate
Example 5 — Web crawler — shared development risk
Annex II Ch.II · Example 5 · ¶20–25 · IT MNE
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
WebCo writes the core web-crawler engine. ScaleCo customises and scales it for market needs, designs add-ons, and decides the crawling strategy. Both contribute unique IP; both assume the development risk that the product fails. What method prices the licence between them?
The parties
WebCo
Designs architecture · writes core code · ongoing base technologysoftware licence
ScaleCo
Scales up · designs add-ons · crawling strategyWhat happens
- WebCo designs the architecture of a web crawler and writes its code, achieving superior speed and efficiency.
- WebCo licenses the programme to ScaleCo.
- ScaleCo scales up the crawler, designs add-ons, customises the product and decides the crawling strategy.
- WebCo continues developing the underlying base technology; ScaleCo uses these developments in scale-up.
- Both WebCo and ScaleCo assume the development risk that the crawler is unsuccessful.
Analysis
Both parties share the development risk (the main economic risk here), and both bring unique and valuable IP.
Which method best prices the licence?
OECD analysis · Profit split most appropriate
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 5 (¶25), the contributions are unique and valuable and both parties share the economically significant development risk, so the transactional profit split is likely to be the most appropriate method. A CUP fails because the IP is unique. Cost-plus on ScaleCo strips out its non-routine contribution and the shared risk it bears.
Key takeaway
Shared assumption of an economically significant risk is itself a trigger for profit split — not just unique and valuable contributions. The two indicators often appear together.
Related: ¶2.130 (unique and valuable contributions) · ¶2.137–2.143 (shared assumption of economically significant risks)