When PS is appropriate
Example 3 — Electronics — manufacturing IP plus distribution IP
Annex II Ch.II · Example 3 · ¶10–15 · Electronics MNE
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A designs, develops and manufactures a new product line using valuable manufacturing know-how. Company B handles cutting-edge marketing (building a valuable trademark) and global distribution using a proprietary forecasting algorithm. Both ends are non-routine — what's the right method?
The parties
Company A
R&D · manufacturing · valuable know-howfinished products
Company B
Marketing (creates trademark) · distribution algorithmWhat happens
- Company A performs R&D, decides research lines and timelines, and manufactures the new product line using its valuable manufacturing know-how.
- Company A sells the products to Company B.
- Company B designs and executes cutting-edge global marketing, building a valuable trademark and goodwill.
- Company B runs global distribution using a proprietary algorithm for demand forecasting and 48-hour fulfilment.
Analysis
Both sides have unique value drivers: Company A's manufacturing IP, and Company B's trademark plus proprietary distribution algorithm.
Which method best prices the sale from A to B?
OECD analysis · Profit split most appropriate
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 3 (¶15), both parties make unique and valuable contributions, so the transactional profit split method is likely to be the most appropriate method. Resale price minus on Company B ignores its non-routine marketing trademark and proprietary algorithm. TNMM on Company A treats it as a routine manufacturer, which contradicts the delineation that its manufacturing IP is itself non-routine.
Key takeaway
Non-routine distribution (a proprietary algorithm, a self-built brand) can be just as unique as non-routine manufacturing. Don't treat a distributor as a routine tested party by reflex.
Related: ¶2.130 (unique and valuable contributions) · Example 4 (same fact pattern, routine distribution)