When PS is appropriate

Example 2 — Tea — soil, blending know-how and a brand

Annex II Ch.II · Example 2 · ¶5–9 · T Group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A Co grows and processes a uniquely flavoured tea using proprietary cultivation and blending know-how. B Co repackages, brands, and sells the tea on premium markets it has built through its own marketing. Both make unique and valuable contributions — what method prices the intercompany sale?
A Co (Country A)
Grows · processes · proprietary blending know-how
processed tea
B Co (parent, Country B)
Owns trademark · runs branding & advertising · sells to market
  1. A Co cultivates land with exceptional soil and develops proprietary growing and blending know-how.
  2. A Co processes the tea (sorting, grading, fermenting, blending, packaging) and sells it to its parent B Co.
  3. B Co repackages and brands the teas for sale in target markets.
  4. B Co's branding features the origin and unique blend; its marketing builds the product range into a market leader commanding premium prices.

Both sides bring something unique: A Co's growing and blending know-how, B Co's trademark and marketing.

Which method best prices the tea sale from A Co to B Co?

OECD analysis · Profit split most appropriate
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 2 (¶9), each party makes unique and valuable contributions — A Co's growing and blending know-how and B Co's trademark and goodwill — so the transactional profit split method is likely to be the most appropriate method. A commodity CUP ignores the very characteristics that produce the premium. A TNMM on A Co would leave A Co's unique know-how unpriced.
Key takeaway
Unique contributions can sit at both ends of a supply chain — on the production side and on the brand/marketing side. When they do, neither end is a good tested party.

Related: ¶2.130 (unique and valuable contributions) · Chapter VI (marketing intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →