Applying the PS method
Example 14 — Choice of profit measure — operating vs gross
Annex II Ch.II · Example 14 · ¶73–77
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same residual setup for two manufacturers A and B with unique intangible expenditure, split on relative intangible expenditure. The illustration shows the consequence of choosing different profit measures (operating profit vs. operating profit before overhead; before vs. after intangible expenditure). Which choice changes the allocation?
The parties
Company A
Manufactures widgets · COGS 60 · IP spend 30 · overhead 3share IP; sell to third parties
Company B
Manufactures widgets · COGS 170 · IP spend 40 · overhead 6What happens
- Companies A and B are two related-party widget manufacturers that each contribute unique and valuable IP and sell to third parties; profit split using a residual approach has been determined as the most appropriate method, with the residual split on relative current-year IP expenditure.
- Sales: A = 100, B = 300. COGS: A = 60, B = 170. Overhead: A = 3, B = 6. Other operating: A = 2, B = 4.
- IP expenditure: A = 30, B = 40 (combined 70). Combined operating profit = 85.
- Step 1: each manufacturer earns COGS + 10% as routine return. A's routine = 6; B's = 17 (total 23).
- Step 2 (a): residual = 85 − 23 = 62, split 30/70 to A (26.57) and 40/70 to B (35.43).
- Step 2 (b): if overhead is excluded from the pool, residual rises to 71; A's net stays at allocate-then-deduct outcome 33.43, B's 51.57.
The questions
A
Scenario 1: should the residual pool be operating profit, or operating profit before overhead is deducted?
Does this choice change the split between A and B?
OECD analysis · Choice matters · must follow delineation
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 14 Scenario 1 (¶74–75), excluding overhead leaves each party responsible for its own overhead — and shifts total profits to A from 32.57 to 33.43 and to B from 52.43 to 51.57. The decision whether to exclude items must follow the accurate delineation of the transaction. The choice is not cosmetic.
B
Scenario 2: the splitter is current-year IP spend. Should the residual pool be measured before or after deducting that same IP spend?
Does this choice affect the split?
OECD analysis · Same allocation when splitter uses current-period expense
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 14 Scenario 2 (¶76–77), when the splitter relies on a category of current-period expense, splitting before vs. after that expense is deducted is mathematically irrelevant — both produce the same allocation. The outcome can differ when the splitter uses accumulated expenditure across prior and current years.
Key takeaway
Choice of profit measure is a substantive decision — not a presentation choice. Decide which costs and items belong in the pool by reference to the accurate delineation. When the splitter and the pool reference the same current-period item, the maths is invariant.
Related: ¶2.155–2.157 (measure of profits to split) · ¶2.165–2.171 (splitting factors)