Applying the PS method
Example 13 — Retail franchise — anticipated vs. actual profits
Annex II Ch.II · Example 13 · ¶64–72 · Retail Group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A grants Company B the right to use Retail Group's know-how and trademark in Country B. Both make unique and valuable contributions. Should the split be applied to anticipated profits or to actual profits? The answer turns on who shares the economically significant risks of commercialisation.
The parties
Company A (parent)
Owns know-how and trademark · in-house brand-buildinglicence of know-how + trademark
Company B (Country B)
Country B retail · in-house marketing team · strong local track recordWhat happens
- Company A has built the trademark and goodwill through intensive marketing; the intangibles are not HTVI.
- Company A grants Company B the right to use the know-how and trademark for fashion retail in Country B.
- Company B has its own marketing team and a track record of building brand recognition in Country B.
- Both parties make unique and valuable contributions; profit split is determined to be the most appropriate method.
The questions
A
Scenario 1: Company A does NOT share in the economically significant risks tied to Company B's marketing and exploitation of the licensed IP.
Split anticipated profits, or actual ones?
OECD analysis · Anticipated profits
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 13 Scenario 1 (¶68–70), where Company A does not share the relevant risks, profit split is applied to anticipated profits (e.g. DCF over an appropriate period, with payment by lump sum or sales-based royalty). Splitting actual profits in this case would have Company A bearing the consequences of risks it does not control or assume. The relative value of contributions sets the split ratio (¶2.158–2.162).
B
Scenario 2: A and B jointly run marketing and distribution and both bear the risks of how Country B commercialisation goes.
Split anticipated profits, or actual ones?
OECD analysis · Actual profits
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 13 Scenario 2 (¶71–72), where both parties share the assumption of the economically significant risks, profit split applies to actual profits achieved from sales by Company B. The relative value of contributions still drives the split ratio. Mechanically locking in anticipated profits would frustrate the risk-sharing the parties have agreed.
Key takeaway
Choice between anticipated and actual profits follows the risk allocation. Risk borne by one party → split anticipated profits; risk shared → split actual profits.
Related: ¶2.158–2.162 (anticipated vs. actual) · Chapter VI · Sections D.2.6.3 and D.2.6.4 (DCF valuation)