Applying the PS method
Example 12 — Residual split alongside a routine distributor
Annex II Ch.II · Example 12 · ¶58–63
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Companies A and B jointly design and manufacture products (highly integrated; shared risks; unique contributions on both sides) and also distribute to their own markets. Company C distributes in Country C — benchmarkable. How do we combine a one-sided method on C with a residual profit split between A and B?
The parties
Companies A & B
Joint design/manufacturing + own-market distribution · unique IPproducts
Company C
Distribution in Country C · benchmarkablesales
External customers
Buy in Countries A, B, CWhat happens
- Companies A and B undertake design and manufacturing in a highly integrated manner and each distributes in its own home market.
- Company C performs benchmarkable marketing and distribution of A's and B's products to customers in Country C.
- Functional analysis: A and B share assumption of the design/manufacturing risks and both make unique and valuable contributions.
- Sales in Countries A, B and C all form part of the relevant profits to be split between A and B.
Analysis
Profit split is right for A and B. Company C is routine — its return can be set with a one-sided method (resale price or TNMM).
How do you build the profit pool and allocate it?
OECD analysis · Residual split between A & B; one-sided return for C
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 12 (¶62–63), Country C sales feed into the pool through C's revenue less C's arm's length return. The first step of the residual approach assigns routine returns to A's and B's benchmarkable functions; step two splits the residual on their relative contributions to it. Including C in the split ignores the determination that C makes no unique and valuable contribution. Excluding Country C sales understates the pool that A's and B's unique contributions actually generate.
Key takeaway
Profit split and one-sided methods coexist. Strip out the routine party's arm's length return first, then split what's left among the parties that make unique and valuable contributions.
Related: ¶2.150–2.154 (residual analysis) · ¶2.165–2.171 (splitting factors)