Applying the PS method
Example 11 — Residual analysis with R&D-cost splitter — worked numbers
Annex II Ch.II · Example 11 · ¶51–57
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
A manufactures a unique component (no reliable CUP); B incorporates it into the finished product (also using unique IP); C distributes (routine). Net combined profit of A and B is 10. Routine manufacturing returns are 10% of manufacturing cost. Residual is to be split on relative R&D expenditure (15 vs 10). What are A's and B's net profits?
The parties
Company A
Designs & manufactures the key component · unique IPcomponent
Company B
Designs & manufactures the finished product · unique IPfinished product
Company C
Distributor · benchmarkable resale marginWhat happens
- Three group affiliates: Company A designs and manufactures a unique key component using its own IP; Company B incorporates that component into the finished product using its own IP; Company C is a routine distributor. No reliable CUP exists for A or B.
- A's sales to B = 50; B's sales to C = 100. Routine return on manufacturing cost = 10%.
- A's manufacturing cost = 15 → routine manufacturing profit for A = 1.5.
- B's manufacturing cost = 20 → routine manufacturing profit for B = 2.0.
- Combined net profit of A and B (before reallocation) = 10. Residual profit = 10 − (1.5 + 2.0) = 6.5.
- Relative R&D expenditure: A = 15, B = 10. Residual split: A = 6.5 × 15/25 = 3.9; B = 6.5 × 10/25 = 2.6.
Analysis
Two-step residual split. Step 1: pay each manufacturer a routine return on its manufacturing cost. Step 2: split what's left in proportion to each side's R&D spend (the established proxy for their relative value contribution).
What net profit does each of A and B end up with?
OECD analysis · A = 5.4 · B = 4.6
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 11 (¶57), A's final net profit is 1.5 + 3.9 = 5.4; B's is 2.0 + 2.6 = 4.6. The routine return rewards manufacturing functions; the residual rewards each party's unique and valuable intangible contribution. Distributing only the residual ignores the routine reward. An equal split is arbitrary — it ignores that R&D expenditure was determined to be a reliable proxy for relative value (¶2.145 in the OECD footnote; broader splitting-factor guidance at ¶2.165–2.171).
Key takeaway
Residual profit split walks in two steps: route the routine returns first, then split what's left on a factor that proxies the relative value of the unique contributions. The note to Example 11 cautions that relative current R&D can need refinement for risk and for legacy IP.
Related: ¶2.165–2.171 (splitting factors) · Section C.5.3.2 Ch.II (legacy IP refinements)