When PS is appropriate

Example 10 — Key component — separate but interdependent risks

Annex II Ch.II · Example 10 · ¶46–50

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A designs, produces and sells a new line of products. Company B has developed a unique key component that is the new line's point of difference and that cannot be used in any other product. Each company separately controls the risks for its own piece — but those risks are tightly interdependent. Method?
Company A
Designs · produces · sells the product line · bears production/sale risks
key component
Company B
Develops the unique key component · bears component-development risks
  1. Company A designs, develops and produces a line of high-tech industrial products.
  2. Company B develops a highly innovative key component, the new generation's point of difference.
  3. The key component is specifically tailored for this product line and cannot be used elsewhere.
  4. Each company performs the control functions and assumes the risks in its own domain — B for the component, A for overall production and sale.
  5. A cannot control (and so does not assume) the risk of how the key component performs.

A and B each carry their own significant risks — but those risks are tightly linked. The product line lives or dies with the component, and the component has no other use.

Which method best prices the component sale?

OECD analysis · Profit split most appropriate
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 10 (¶49), although A and B each assume separate economically significant risks, those risks are highly inter-dependent — so profit split is most appropriate. Per ¶50, splitting revenues or gross profits from the new product would also leave each party bearing the consequences of its own operating costs. A TNMM on Company B ignores its unique component IP; a CUP fails because the component is bespoke and has no other use.
Key takeaway
Risk allocation is not binary. Risks can be separately assumed but closely related — and that interdependence is itself a profit-split indicator. Splitting at the gross-profit line keeps each party's own cost discipline.

Related: ¶2.137–2.143 (closely related risks) · ¶2.155–2.157 (measure of profits to split)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →