Applying the PS method

Example 15 — Asset-based splitting factor

Annex II Ch.II · Example 15 · ¶78–82

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Companies A and B jointly design and manufacture in a highly integrated way, share the assumption of design/manufacturing risks, and each makes unique and valuable contributions. There are no comparable uncontrolled transactions and no direct evidence of how independents would split. What splitting factor is appropriate?
Company A (Country A)
Design + manufacturing · sells in Country A · unique IP
components, moulds, semi-finished products ↔
Company B (Country B)
Design + manufacturing · sells in Country B · unique IP
  1. Companies A and B run highly integrated design and manufacturing operations.
  2. They exchange components, moulds and semi-finished products as needed to meet customer demand.
  3. Each company has developed unique and valuable design and manufacturing know-how.
  4. Risk analysis: A and B share assumption of the design/manufacturing risks; both perform relevant control functions.
  5. No comparable uncontrolled transactions exist; no direct evidence of how independents would have split.

Profit split is the right method. With no CUPs and no evidence of how independents would split, the team is considering an asset-based splitting factor. Asset creation appears to track value creation here.

Can an asset-based splitter be used?

OECD analysis · Asset-based splitter (subject to correlation test)
Per Annex II Ch.II · Example 15 (¶82), an asset-based splitter may be appropriate provided the functional analysis concludes that there is a strong correlation between the assets of A and B and the creation of value in their controlled transactions. Expense-based splitters are not the only option (¶2.176–2.181); asset-based splitters are not always preferred — the right splitter depends on the facts.
Key takeaway
There is no default splitter. Pick the factor that has a strong, demonstrable correlation with the value created by the parties' unique contributions. Cost, asset, headcount, time — all are possible; all need justification.

Related: ¶2.165–2.171 (selecting splitting factors) · ¶2.176–2.181 (asset-based splitters)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →