Choosing the tested party (Ch.III)

Example 8 — Two products, one manufacturer: choosing the tested party

Chapter III · ¶3.19 · Company A · Company B

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A manufactures P1 and P2 and sells both product types to Company B, an associated enterprise in a different country. For P1 the valuable, unique intangibles and the technical specifications are B's; for P2 the valuable, unique intangibles are A's own and B acts as distributor. Which company would most often be the tested party for each product?
Company A
Manufactures P1 and P2 · owns the intangibles used for P2
sales of P1 and P2
Company B
In another country · owns the intangibles used for P1 · distributor of P2
  1. Company A is the manufacturer of two types of products, P1 and P2.
  2. Company B, which buys both from A, is an associated enterprise in a different country.
  3. A makes P1 with valuable, unique intangibles belonging to B and works to technical specifications that B sets.
  4. For P2, the valuable, unique intangibles (such as valuable patents and trademarks) are ones that A itself owns and uses, and B acts as distributor.
A

P1: the valuable, unique intangibles used to make the product belong to B, and B sets the technical specifications that A follows. A's own part in the transaction is limited to simple functions, with no valuable, unique contribution.

Which company would most often be the tested party for the P1 transaction?

OECD analysis · Most often Company A
A tested party is needed whenever a cost plus, resale price or transactional net margin method is applied, and the choice should be in line with the functional analysis of the transaction (¶3.18). The general rule turns on reliability: the tested party is the one for which the method, and the comparables found for it, are the most reliable, and that will most often be the party with the less complex functional analysis. For P1 the valuable, unique intangibles belong to B, while A performs only simple functions and makes no valuable, unique contribution. On those facts A is the party that would most often be tested for P1.
B

P2: the valuable, unique intangibles, such as valuable patents and trademarks, are owned and used by A, and B's role is that of distributor. B's part in the transaction is limited to simple functions, with no valuable, unique contribution.

Which company would most often be the tested party for the P2 transaction?

OECD analysis · Most often Company B
For P2 the positions are reversed. A owns and uses the valuable, unique intangibles, such as valuable patents and trademarks, while B acts as distributor, performs only simple functions and makes no valuable, unique contribution. B is therefore the party that would most often be tested for P2. The same two companies would thus most often have a different tested party for each product, because what guides the choice is the functional analysis of each transaction (¶3.18).
Key takeaway
The tested party should be chosen for each transaction in line with its functional analysis, and will most often be the party with the less complex functional analysis. Between the same two companies that may be the manufacturer for one product and the distributor for another.

Related: Section A.3.3 of Chapter III, ¶3.18 (general rule on the choice of the tested party) · Chapter II (cost plus, resale price and transactional net margin methods, for which a tested party is chosen)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →