Working capital adjustment

Example 1 — Working capital adjustment

Annex to Ch.III · Working capital adjustment · ¶1–8 (cross-ref ¶3.47–3.54) · TestCo vs CompCo · TNMM benchmarking

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
TestCo and CompCo carry materially different levels of receivables, inventory and payables. Should the comparable's result be adjusted before reading off an arm's-length range — and if so, how?
TestCo
Tested party (R + I − P ≈ 26% of sales)
comparability adjustment
CompCo
Selected comparable (R + I − P ≈ 24% of sales, fluctuating)
  1. TNMM is the most appropriate method; EBIT/Sales is the chosen indicator.
  2. Five years of data are gathered for TestCo and one external comparable, CompCo.
  3. Working-capital levels (R + I − P / Sales) differ materially between TestCo (~25–29%) and CompCo (~20–29%, swinging).
  4. Analyst weighs whether to adjust CompCo's EBIT/Sales before testing TestCo against the range.
A

TestCo carries more working capital than CompCo (longer customer credit and inventory days). Reliable yearly receivables, inventory and payables data are available for CompCo, plus a market interest rate.

Should the comparable's result be adjusted for the working-capital gap?

OECD analysis · Adjust — when reliability improves
Annex to Ch.III · ¶1 and ¶8: working-capital adjustments may be warranted under TNMM (and, less commonly, cost plus or resale price) when the reliability of the comparables WILL BE IMPROVED and reasonably accurate adjustments can be made. They should not be made automatically and would not automatically be accepted by tax administrations. Adjusting mechanically for every difference misses the reliability test; refusing adjustments altogether ignores ¶3.47–3.54 of the Guidelines.
B

Time to pick the interest rate. TestCo borrows locally at ~5%; CompCo's market has very different rates. The analyst is using period-end balances.

Whose borrowing rate should be used — and what should the analyst flag?

OECD analysis · Tested-party borrowing rate
Annex to Ch.III · ¶8: the interest rate should generally be determined by reference to the rate(s) applicable to a commercial enterprise operating in the same market AS THE TESTED PARTY — in most cases a commercial loan rate. A negative working-capital balance may warrant a different rate. The example also flags that period-end balances may not be representative and averages might be better. Picking the rate to maximise outcome, or defaulting to risk-free, both ignore the OECD's reliability framing.
Key takeaway
Working-capital adjustments under TNMM are a reliability tool, not a default. Make them when the differences are material AND reasonably measurable, use the tested party's market-rate borrowing cost, and watch the timing point (period-end vs averages).

Related: ¶3.47–3.54 (general guidance on comparability adjustments) · ¶2.64 (selecting the base for TNMM) · Chapter III Section A.6 (comparability adjustments)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →