Example 1 — Working capital adjustment
Annex to Ch.III · Working capital adjustment · ¶1–8 (cross-ref ¶3.47–3.54) · TestCo vs CompCo · TNMM benchmarking
OECD Guidelines 2022The parties
What happens
- TNMM is the most appropriate method; EBIT/Sales is the chosen indicator.
- Five years of data are gathered for TestCo and one external comparable, CompCo.
- Working-capital levels (R + I − P / Sales) differ materially between TestCo (~25–29%) and CompCo (~20–29%, swinging).
- Analyst weighs whether to adjust CompCo's EBIT/Sales before testing TestCo against the range.
The questions
TestCo carries more working capital than CompCo (longer customer credit and inventory days). Reliable yearly receivables, inventory and payables data are available for CompCo, plus a market interest rate.
Should the comparable's result be adjusted for the working-capital gap?
Time to pick the interest rate. TestCo borrows locally at ~5%; CompCo's market has very different rates. The analyst is using period-end balances.
Whose borrowing rate should be used — and what should the analyst flag?
Related: ¶3.47–3.54 (general guidance on comparability adjustments) · ¶2.64 (selecting the base for TNMM) · Chapter III Section A.6 (comparability adjustments)