Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)

Example 7 — Development CCA — funder with no risk control

Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 5 · ¶21–22 (cross-ref ¶8.15) · Companies A & B · development CCA, no risk control at A

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same development CCA as Example 4 — except A's functional analysis reveals no capability to decide on, mitigate, or even monitor the risks it has contractually assumed. Does A still earn a share of the output?
Company A
Contractual funder; NO capacity to control CCA risks
delineation under ¶8.15
Company B
Pre-existing intangibles, R&D activity, AND risk control
  1. Same starting facts as Example 4: A funds, B contributes IP + R&D, intangible expected to generate USD 550m/yr.
  2. Functional analysis: A has no capacity to decide on or decline the risks under the CCA, no capability to mitigate them, and cannot assess B's risk-mitigation activities.
  3. Accurate delineation of the transactions associated with the CCA proceeds under Section D.1 of Chapter I and ¶8.15.
  4. Conclusion changes: A is no longer treated as a participant entitled to a share in the CCA output.

A is a participant on paper only — no people, no decisions, no ability to mitigate or even assess the risks. B does everything that matters.

Is A still entitled to a share of the CCA's output?

OECD analysis · Not a participant — no output share
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 5 · ¶22 is explicit: where the functional analysis shows that A does not control its specific risks under the CCA in accordance with ¶8.15, A is not entitled to a share in the output of the CCA. This mirrors the control-of-risk framework in Section D.1 of Chapter I — a contractual allocation of risk to a party that doesn't control it (and doesn't have the financial capacity to bear it) doesn't hold for TP purposes. That funding alone is enough is exactly what ¶8.15 rules out, and a discounted share of the output would be a half-measure the OECD doesn't endorse.
Key takeaway
Funding without risk control doesn't make you a participant in a CCA. The control-of-risk test (¶8.15, echoing Section D.1 of Ch.I) decides who is in the arrangement for TP purposes — and contractual designations don't override it.

Related: ¶8.15 (control of risk in a CCA) · Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I (six-step risk framework) · Example 4 (same facts, with risk control intact)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →