Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)

Example 6 — Development CCA — funding vs pre-existing intangibles

Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 4 · ¶17–20 (cross-ref ¶8.14–8.18) · Companies A & B · development CCA

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A funds the R&D; B brings pre-existing intangibles and runs the development. Anticipated profits are USD 550m/yr; A is allocated USD 330m/yr in benefits but its arm's-length funding return is only USD 110m/yr. Who owes whom — and how much?
Company A
Funder of R&D (USD 100m/yr × 5 years); RoW exploitation rights
development CCA — funding + IP
Company B
Pre-existing intangibles + all R&D activity; Country B rights
  1. 5-year development phase: A contributes USD 100m/yr funding; B contributes pre-existing intangibles + performs all R&D activities.
  2. Years 6–15: intangible expected to generate USD 550m/yr globally — A gets RoW (USD 330m/yr); B gets Country B (USD 220m/yr).
  3. A's arm's-length funding return for that risk level is determined to be USD 110m/yr (years 6–15).
  4. A is anticipated to reap USD 330m/yr — more than 3× its funding return. Where does the excess belong?

A actually controls the risks it took on. Its arm's-length funding return is 110m/yr — but the CCA structure hands A 330m/yr. The 220m/yr excess reflects the value of B's pre-existing IP and its R&D work.

What balancing payment fixes the result?

OECD analysis · A pays B — for the pre-existing IP
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 4 · ¶20. A's contribution is funding; B's contribution combines pre-existing intangibles AND the development activity. A's arm's-length return for the funding risk is USD 110m/yr — but the CCA hands A anticipated profits of USD 330m/yr. The excess of USD 220m/yr per year (in PV terms) is properly attributable to B's pre-existing contributions and must be paid to B as a balancing payment. A payment from B to A would mistake funding for the principal economic contribution; no payment at all would ignore that the territorial split itself only makes sense once B's pre-existing IP is paid for.
Key takeaway
In development CCAs, funding earns a funding return — not a residual. When the territorial split hands the funder more than its risk-adjusted funding return, the excess belongs to the participant that brought the pre-existing intangibles and ran the development.

Related: ¶8.14–8.18 (control of risk in a CCA) · Chapter VI (IP valuation — for valuing B's contribution) · Example 5 (same facts, but A lacks risk control)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →