Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)

Example 5 — Identical mark-up doesn't justify cost-based contributions

Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 3 · ¶15–16 · Companies A & B · symmetric-margin services CCA

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Now both services have the SAME 20% mark-up (cost 100, value 120). Surely you can just use cost — the mark-up is the same on both sides? Wrong. Here's why.
Company A
Service 1 (cost 100, value 120) — 30 units
symmetric margins, asymmetric volumes
Company B
Service 2 (cost 100, value 120) — 20 units
  1. Two related companies A and B run a services CCA: A produces Service 1 (cost 100/unit, value 120 — 30 units), B produces Service 2 (cost 100/unit, value 120 — 20 units). Each consumes 50% of each.
  2. Both services now carry the same 20% mark-up over cost.
  3. At value: total 6 000, each bears 3 000, B tops up A by 600.
  4. At cost: total 5 000, each bears 2 500, B tops up A by 500.

Both services carry the same 20% mark-up. Surely measuring contributions at cost would give the same answer as measuring at value?

Does the identical mark-up rescue the cost-based shortcut?

OECD analysis · At value — even with equal mark-ups
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 3 · ¶16. Identical mark-up does NOT make at-cost equivalent to at-value, because the volumes (and therefore the absolute values) of each party's contribution differ. The example expressly illustrates that assessing contributions at cost will not result in an arm's-length outcome 'even in those situations in which the arm's length mark-up on the cost of contributions is identical.' The intuition that consumption symmetry rescues the cost approach also fails for the same reason.
Key takeaway
Don't be fooled by symmetric margins. Where contribution VOLUMES differ, contributions must still be valued at value to produce an arm's-length result. Symmetric mark-ups are a red herring.

Related: Example 1 (general at-value rule) · Example 2 (low-value services exception — narrow)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →