Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)
Example 4 — Low-value services — cost as a practical proxy
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 2 · ¶12–14 · Companies A & B · low-margin services CCA
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same CCA as Example 1, but the cost-to-value gap on each service is small enough that valuing contributions at cost produces broadly the same answer as valuing at value. Practical shortcut or sloppy practice?
The parties
Company A
Service 1 (cost 100, value 103 per unit) — low marginlow-value services CCA
Company B
Service 2 (cost 100, value 105 per unit) — low marginWhat happens
- Two related companies A and B run a services CCA: A produces Service 1, B produces Service 2, and each consumes 50% of each.
- Both services are low-margin: Service 1 = 103/unit, Service 2 = 105/unit (cost 100 each).
- 30 units of Service 1 + 20 units of Service 2 produced; each company consumes 50% of each.
- At value: total contributions 5 190, each bears 2 595, B tops up A by 495.
- At cost: total cost 5 000, each bears 2 500, B tops up A by 500.
Analysis
The gap between at-value (495) and at-cost (500) is small, and the services are low-value in nature. The analyst wants a shortcut.
Can contributions be measured at cost here?
OECD analysis · At cost OK for low-value services
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 2 · ¶14. Where all contributions are LOW-VALUE SERVICES, the practical approach of valuing at cost will produce results broadly consistent with the arm's-length principle. The Example 1 rule still holds in general; Example 2 carves out a tightly scoped practical exception. Identical numbers of units or identical costs are not the OECD's condition — what matters is that the contributions themselves are low-value in nature.
Key takeaway
Contributions-at-value is the default, but for low-value services the practical at-cost approach gives a result close enough to be acceptable. The exception is narrow: it's about the NATURE of the contribution, not the convenience of the analyst.
Related: Example 1 (general at-value rule) · Ch.VII Section D (low value-adding intra-group services framework)