Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)

Example 3 — Two-step method — costs plus a separate value payment

Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 1A · ¶8–11 (cross-ref ¶8.27) · Companies A & B · services CCA

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same facts as Example 1 — but instead of valuing all contributions at value up front, the parties run the CCA in two steps: a cost-share now, plus a separate payment for the additional value contributed. Does the answer change?
Company A
Same as Example 1: Service 1 at cost 100, value 120
two-step CCA settlement
Company B
Same as Example 1: Service 2 at cost 100, value 105
  1. Two related companies A and B run a services CCA. A produces Service 1 (cost 100/unit, arm's-length value 120 — 30 units/year); B produces Service 2 (cost 100/unit, arm's-length value 105 — 20 units/year); each consumes 50% of both.
  2. Step 1: contributions measured at COST. Total cost 5 000 → each bears 50% = 2 500.
  3. A's cost contribution = 3 000; B's = 2 000. B pays A 500 (cost-share balancing payment).
  4. Step 2: account for the additional VALUE A contributes above cost.
  5. A consumes 10 units of Service 2 (value-over-cost 50); B consumes 15 units of Service 1 (value-over-cost 300). Net additional value from A = 250.

Step 1 transferred 500 from B to A (cost-share). Step 2 settles the value-over-cost differential: A's added value (300 − 50 = 250) means B owes A another 250.

What's the total flow B → A — and how does it compare with the at-value answer from Example 1?

OECD analysis · Same answer (750) — different mechanics
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 1A · ¶9–11. The two-step approach (¶8.27) reaches the same answer (750) as contributions-at-value: 500 for the cost share + 250 for A's additional value contribution. ¶11 flags that the two-step method is particularly useful for DEVELOPMENT CCAs where one participant brings pre-existing contributions (e.g. intangibles). Stopping after Step 1 (a payment of 500) would systematically under-compensate the higher-value provider, and Step 2 is itself a net figure: the 300 of extra value B receives, less the 50 that A receives.
Key takeaway
The two-step method (¶8.27) is operationally different but economically equivalent to contributions-at-value: cost-share now, plus a separate payment for the additional value (often pre-existing intangibles) brought to the CCA. Most useful for development CCAs.

Related: ¶8.27 (two-step alternative) · Example 1 (one-step contributions at value) · Example 4 (development CCA, where the two-step framing is most natural)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →