Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)
Example 2 — Services CCA — contributions at value, not at cost
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 1 · ¶1–7 · Companies A & B · services CCA
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
A and B each provide one service to the CCA; each consumes 50% of both. The two services have different cost/value margins. Should contributions be measured at cost or at value — and what balancing payment falls out?
The parties
Company A
Provides Service 1 (cost 100, value 120 per unit) — 30 units/yearCCA — both consume 50% of total
Company B
Provides Service 2 (cost 100, value 105 per unit) — 20 units/yearWhat happens
- A produces Service 1 at cost 100/unit; arm's-length charge would be 120 → 30 units = cost 3 000, value 3 600.
- B produces Service 2 at cost 100/unit; arm's-length charge would be 105 → 20 units = cost 2 000, value 2 100.
- Each company consumes 50% of total contributions (value 2 850 each).
- Need to determine the balancing payment from B to A.
Analysis
Total value of contributions = 5 700, so each side should bear 2 850. A's contribution at value is 3 600; B's is 2 100. If there were no CCA, A and B buying these services from each other on the open market would result in net 750 flowing from B to A.
What balancing payment from B to A makes the CCA arm's-length?
OECD analysis · Balancing payment 750 — at value
Annex to Ch.VIII · Example 1 · ¶5–7. Under the CCA, each participant's contribution should correspond to its proportionate share of expected benefits (50%). At value, A contributes 3 600 and B contributes 2 100, so B must top up by 750. Crucially, the alternative-to-the-CCA scenario (independent market purchases) yields exactly 750 from B to A — confirming that contributions-at-value is the route to an arm's-length outcome. Measuring contributions at cost, which would give a payment of 500 (¶6), systematically under-compensates the higher-value provider.
Key takeaway
Contributions to a CCA are assessed at value (arm's-length price), not at cost — that is the only way to produce results consistent with the arm's-length principle. The exception (low-value contributions where cost ≈ value) appears in Example 2.
Related: ¶8.26 (contributions at value) · ¶8.27 (alternative two-step method — see Example 1A) · Example 2 (low-value services exception)