Cost contribution arrangements (Ch.VIII)

Example 9 — Contributions and benefits in a 75:25 development CCA

Chapter VIII · ¶8.33, 8.38 · Company A · Company B · development CCA

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A and Company B conclude a CCA to develop intangibles, expecting 75% of the benefits to go to A and 25% to B. Each makes a pre-existing contribution, valued in the first year at 10 million for A and 6 million for B. Do the contributions match the expected benefits and, if not, who owes whom a balancing payment, and how much?
Company A
Country A · rest-of-world rights · 75% of expected benefits
CCA to develop intangibles
Company B
Country B · Country B rights · 25% of expected benefits

Each company is experienced in developing intangibles, has its own R&D personnel and controls its development risk under the CCA (¶8.14–8.16).

  1. Two members of an MNE group, Company A in Country A and Company B in Country B, enter into a CCA to develop intangibles; it entitles B to exploit them in Country B, while the rest of the world is for A to exploit.
  2. Sales are expected to split 75% for A and 25% for B, and the parties put their shares of the expected benefits from the CCA at 75:25.
  3. As pre-existing contributions, A brings in intangibles recently acquired from a third party and B brings in proprietary analytical techniques that it developed to improve efficiency and speed to market.
  4. The current contributions are of two kinds: day-to-day research, of which B is to perform 80% and A 20%, and its guidance by a leadership team staffed 90:10 in A's favour by the two companies.
  5. The pre-existing contributions are valued, in the first year, at 10 million (Company A) and 6 million (Company B).

Expected benefits are shared 75:25 between Company A and Company B. In the first year, A's pre-existing contribution is worth 10 million and B's 6 million.

What balancing payment, if any, do these figures require?

OECD analysis · A pays B 2 million
Where participants' shares of the value contributed are out of line with their shares of the expected benefits, the arm's-length principle would generally require an adjustment, generally through a balancing payment (¶8.34). The pre-existing contributions come to 16 million, of which a 75:25 split would be 12 million for Company A and 4 million for Company B, against the 10 million and 6 million contributed. Company A is therefore required to pay Company B a net 2 million, since a balancing payment adds to the payer's contribution and reduces the payee's. The text sets the 2 million out as 4.5 million from A to B less 2.5 million from B to A (the working is not shown, but these equal 75% of B's 6 million and 25% of A's 10 million). The calculation covers the pre-existing contributions only: the text puts no value on the two kinds of current contributions, which ¶8.33 says should each be analysed and valued separately.
Key takeaway
Each participant's share of the value contributed to a CCA should be in line with its share of the expected benefits. Where it is not, the arm's-length principle would generally require a balancing payment, which adds to the payer's contribution and reduces the payee's.

Related: Section C.5 of Chapter VIII, ¶8.34–8.37 (balancing payments) · ¶8.14–8.16 (determining participants: control of risk) · Sections D.3 and D.4 of Chapter VI (hard-to-value intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →