Risk reallocation & recognition

Example 9 — Central procurement company and group purchasing power

Ch.IX · ¶9.25 · MNE group · central procurement

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
An MNE group restructures by creating a central procurement operation that takes over the procurement of several associated enterprises, to benefit from volume discounts and possible savings in administrative costs. The new company may also take on, by contract, the risk of buying, holding and on-selling goods. Which profits is it entitled to?
Central procurement company
Single group company · purchasing centralised here · may contractually assume buying, holding and on-selling risk
centralised procurement
Several associated enterprises
Group members · their own procurement activities are replaced
  1. Several associated enterprises in an MNE group each carry out their own procurement activities.
  2. In a business restructuring, the group sets up a central procurement operation that replaces those activities.
  3. Purchasing is deliberately centralised in a single group company so as to benefit from volume discounts and, potentially, lower administrative costs.
  4. By contract, the central procurement company may also take on the risk that comes with buying, holding and on-selling goods.

Here the central procurement company also takes on, by contract, the risk of buying, holding and on-selling goods. The volume discounts are a benefit of the group's purchasing power, which the group has deliberately combined in this one company.

Which profits is the central procurement company entitled to?

OECD analysis · Risk-related profit, not synergies
Centralising purchasing in a single company to obtain volume discounts is a deliberate concerted group action, and under the guidance in Chapter I the resulting benefits should be attributed to the enterprises that contribute to creating the synergies. The central procurement company makes no contribution to creating those synergies, so the profits that stem from the group's purchasing power are not its to keep. What it is entitled to is the profit potential that comes with the risk it assumes in buying, holding and on-selling goods. How economically significant that risk is, and which party or parties assume it, is determined under the risk framework of Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I.
Key takeaway
A central procurement company can earn the profit potential that goes with the risk it assumes, but it does not keep the benefit of the group's purchasing power. Where a group deliberately pools its buying, the synergy benefits that result should be allocated to the group members whose contributions generate them.

Related: Section B.2 of Part I (business reasons for the restructuring, including the role of synergies) · Section D.8 of Chapter I (MNE group synergies), in particular ¶1.180 and ¶1.188 · Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I (analysis of risks)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →