Post-restructuring TP & location savings
Example 8 — Location savings on a manufacturing relocation
Ch.IX · ¶9.126–9.131 · MNE Group · brand-name clothing manufacturer
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
A high-cost-country brand owner moves basic clothing manufacturing to a low-cost-country affiliate operating as a contract manufacturer. Significant location savings emerge. Who keeps them?
The parties
Brand-A (Country A)
Designer, brand owner; on-sells finished goods to customerscontract manufacturing
Contract Mfr-B (Country B)
Low-cost-country affiliate; no significant intangibles or risksfinished goods · brand price
Customers
Third-party buyersWhat happens
- Brand-A designs and previously manufactured high-end branded clothing in Country A (high labour cost).
- Manufacturing is relocated to affiliate Contract Mfr-B in Country B (significantly lower labour cost).
- Brand-A retains the brand and design IP; Contract Mfr-B holds no significant intangibles and bears no significant risks.
- Finished goods flow back to Brand-A, which on-sells to third-party customers; significant location savings emerge.
Analysis
Manufacturing is a competitive activity — Brand-A could just as easily use a third-party Country B manufacturer, and reliable local comparables exist.
Who keeps the location savings?
OECD analysis · Location savings follow the comparables
¶9.129 is exactly on point: where the relocated activity is highly competitive and reliable comparables exist for the low-cost market, an arm's-length contract manufacturer would generally be attributed very little, if any, of the location savings — to do otherwise would put the associated manufacturer in a position different from an independent contract manufacturer in the same market, contrary to the arm's-length principle. ¶9.131 generalises: the allocation turns on functions/risks/assets and the options realistically available to each party.
Key takeaway
Location savings aren't 'free money' for the low-cost entity. Where reliable local comparables exist and the relocated activity is commoditised, the contract manufacturer earns a market return on those comparables — the location savings sit with the party that has the realistic alternatives and the bargaining power.
Related: Section E of Part II (¶9.126–9.131 location savings) · Section D.6 of Chapter I (location savings, options realistically available) · Example 6 (transfer of ongoing concern)