Post-restructuring TP & location savings
Example 7 — Loss-making LRD post-conversion
Ch.IX · ¶9.105, 9.108 · MNE Group · post-restructuring review
inRange illustration, not an OECD exampleAt a glance
A freshly-converted LRD records a loss in its first post-restructuring year. The benchmark range for LRDs is firmly positive. What does the loss mean — for the conversion, the post-restructuring TP, or both?
The parties
LRD-A (was FFD-A)
Restructured limited-risk distributorpost-restructuring transactions
Principal-B
Foreign principal under the new structureWhat happens
- FFD-A was converted to LRD-A at year-start; pre-restructuring functions, expenses (incl. marketing), risks and possibly intangibles existed in FFD-A.
- LRD-A is benchmarked to an LRD range with a firmly positive lower quartile.
- First post-restructuring year: LRD-A records a loss.
- Tax administration audits.
Analysis
A closer look shows LRD-A still owns local marketing intangibles and still controls some market risk — unlike the long-established LRDs in the comparable set.
What's the most likely explanation for the loss, and what does it imply?
Analysis · Substance over label
¶9.105 flags that a long-established FFD that becomes an LRD may have performed functions, borne expenses (including marketing) and developed intangibles before conversion — and these should affect either the pricing of the transfers at conversion or the post-restructuring LRD return (or both). ¶9.108 reinforces that labels don't dictate the TP: 'an entity that is labelled as a limited risk distributor can sometimes be found to own valuable local intangibles and to continue to assume significant market risks.' A loss alongside retained intangibles/risks is a signal that the substance disagrees with the label.
Key takeaway
Labels don't drive the TP. When a post-restructuring 'LRD' is loss-making and the functional review shows retained intangibles or market risks, either the conversion was under-priced (¶9.105) or the post-restructuring TP is mischaracterising the entity (¶9.108) — usually a bit of both.
Related: Section A of Part II (¶9.100–9.107 restructured vs newly set-up operations) · Section B of Part II (¶9.108 post-restructuring method) · Example 1 (compensation at conversion) · Example 4 (substance over contract on risk)