Compensation for the restructuring itself
Example 6 — Transfer of an ongoing concern
Ch.IX · ¶9.68–9.70 · MNE Group · manufacturing relocation
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Manufacturing moves from M1 to M2: machinery, inventory, patents, processes, supplier and customer contracts — and key employees. Three valuation routes are on the table. Which one is right?
The parties
M1
Pre-restructuring manufacturer (transferor)ongoing concern transfer
M2
Post-restructuring manufacturer (transferee, in a lower-cost jurisdiction)What happens
- M1 has been manufacturing in a high-cost jurisdiction; the group plans to relocate manufacturing to M2 in a lower-cost jurisdiction.
- M1 transfers to M2: machinery and equipment, inventories, patents, manufacturing processes and know-how, key contracts with suppliers and clients.
- Several key M1 employees relocate to M2 to assist with start-up.
- Comparable transactions between independent parties would treat this as a single integrated transfer.
Analysis
Between independents this would be the transfer of an ongoing concern. The relocated workforce is a real part of what M2 gets — saving time and money.
Which valuation route fits at arm's length?
OECD analysis · Ongoing-concern valuation
¶9.68 frames the situation: an ongoing concern is a functioning, economically integrated business unit; the valuation should reflect all valuable elements that would be remunerated between independent parties, including the impact of the assembled workforce. ¶9.69: the price does NOT necessarily equal the sum of separate valuations. ¶9.70: the transfer should be compared with a transfer of an ongoing concern between independent parties, not with a transfer of isolated assets. Setting only a post-restructuring cost-plus margin ignores the conversion itself.
Key takeaway
When the package is functionally integrated — assets + workforce + contracts + the capacity to carry on the business — the right arm's-length price is for the whole ongoing concern, not the sum of the parts. The assembled workforce is part of the value, not a free rider.
Related: Section E.3 of Part I (¶9.68–9.73 ongoing concern) · Section D.7 of Chapter I (assembled workforce) · Section A.4.6 of Chapter VI (goodwill / ongoing concern value) · Example 2 (IP centralisation as ongoing concern)