Compensation for the restructuring itself
Example 5 — Indemnification on contract termination
Ch.IX · ¶9.75–9.79, 9.88 · MNE Group · distribution termination
inRange illustration, not an OECD exampleAt a glance
Principal-B terminates Distributor-A's distribution agreement unilaterally, before the end of its term. A seeks indemnification. Is it owed — and on what test?
The parties
Distributor-A
Restructured entity (terminated counter-party)termination
Principal-B
Counter-party that terminated the arrangementWhat happens
- Distributor-A and Principal-B have a distribution agreement with several years left on its term.
- Principal-B terminates the agreement with limited notice as part of a group-wide restructuring.
- Distributor-A claims indemnification.
- Counsel and TP need to determine whether any indemnification is owed and, if so, how much.
Analysis
The contract has no indemnification clause. But commercial law would support an indemnification claim — and independent parties in similar deals would normally have negotiated some protection.
Is indemnification owed at arm's length?
Analysis · Indemnification likely warranted
¶9.78 states there is no presumption that all terminations give a right to indemnification — facts and circumstances matter. ¶9.79 sets out the three aspects: commercial-law rights; whether the existence or absence of an indemnification clause (and its terms) is arm's length; and which party should ultimately bear the cost. On these facts the law supports a claim AND independent parties would have priced in some indemnification, so the arrangement as accurately delineated does not pass the arm's-length test without one.
Key takeaway
Termination indemnification isn't automatic and isn't excluded by the absence of an express clause. The arm's-length test runs through ¶9.79: commercial-law support → would independent parties have agreed to an indemnification clause → who bears the cost.
Related: Section F of Part I (¶9.75–9.97 indemnification framework) · Section D.1 of Chapter I (accurate delineation) · Example 1 (compensation at conversion)