Risk reallocation & recognition

Example 4 — Risk reallocated to a low-substance principal

Ch.IX · ¶9.19–9.23, cross-ref Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I · MNE Group · risk-transfer audit

inRange illustration, not an OECD example
At a glance
The contract reallocates bad-debt and inventory risk from the local distributor to a foreign principal. The principal has no people with credit or inventory decision-making roles and no balance sheet to absorb a loss. Does the contractual reallocation hold?
Distributor-A
Pre-restructuring full-fledged distributor (post: contractually 'limited-risk')
risk reallocation under the contract
Principal-B
Foreign principal contractually allocated bad-debt + inventory risk
  1. Pre-restructuring: Distributor-A bears bad-debt and inventory risk under its contracts and balance sheet.
  2. Group signs a new master contract reallocating those risks to Principal-B.
  3. Functional review: Principal-B has no relevant decision-making staff (credit-line decisions and inventory write-down decisions still happen in A); B has no financial capacity to absorb a write-down of the size at stake.
  4. Tax administration in Country A challenges the post-restructuring TP.

On paper the risks moved to Principal-B. In practice, Distributor-A still makes the credit and inventory calls — and Principal-B can't even afford the losses it has contractually accepted.

Where do the risks really sit for transfer pricing?

Analysis · Risk follows control + capacity
¶9.20 directs the analyst to Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I: the party that assumes risk must control it (relevant capability + decision-making per ¶1.65) AND have the financial capacity to bear it (¶1.64). ¶9.21 spells out the consequence: 'a party that after the restructuring does not assume a risk under the analysis of Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I should not be allocated the profit potential associated with that risk.' Contractual reallocation, on its own, is not enough.
Key takeaway
A bare contractual reallocation of risk doesn't move the profit potential. Under Section D.1.2.1 of Ch.I (echoed in ¶9.20–9.21), the risk — and the associated return — follows the party that actually controls it AND has the financial capacity to bear it.

Related: Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I (six-step risk framework) · Example 3 (recognition vs disregard) · Example 1 (FF→LRD conversion)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →