Risk reallocation & recognition
Example 3 — Recognition or disregard of the restructuring
Ch.IX · ¶9.34–9.38, cross-ref Section D.2 of Chapter I (¶1.142) · MNE Group · principal in a low-tax jurisdiction
inRange illustration, not an OECD exampleAt a glance
A restructuring takes a form rarely seen between independent enterprises and the principal sits in a low-tax jurisdiction. A tax administration is tempted to disregard it. What's the test — and how high is the bar?
The parties
Operating co-A
Restructured entity (post: stripped-risk distributor)post-restructuring transactions
Principal-B
Low-tax-jurisdiction principal under the new structureWhat happens
- Group restructures so that Operating co-A becomes a stripped-risk distributor for Principal-B.
- Principal-B sits in a low-tax jurisdiction; the model is uncommon between independent enterprises.
- Country A's tax administration considers whether to disregard the restructuring under domestic and treaty rules.
- The accurate-delineation framework of Section D.1 of Ch.I has been applied and all relevant facts are known.
Analysis
Each entity is commercially rational given its options — even if the structure is unusual. There's a tax motive, but also real business substance.
Can the tax administration disregard the restructuring?
Analysis · Price the structure — don't disregard it lightly
¶9.34: MNEs are free to organise their business as they see fit. ¶9.35: a tax administration should not disregard part or all of a restructuring unless the exceptional circumstances described in ¶1.142 are met (Section D.2 of Chapter I). ¶9.38: the fact that a restructuring is motivated by tax benefits does not, of itself, warrant a conclusion that it is non-arm's-length, nor justify non-recognition. The right discipline is accurate delineation first, non-recognition only as a last resort.
Key takeaway
Non-recognition is a high bar. The default discipline is accurate delineation under Section D.1 of Ch.I: characterise what is actually happening and price it. Only in the exceptional ¶1.142 circumstances can the tax administration disregard or substitute the parties' arrangement.
Related: Section D.2 of Chapter I (non-recognition, ¶1.142) · Section D.1 of Chapter I (accurate delineation) · Example 4 (risk control under the same framework)