Compensation for the restructuring itself

Example 2 — Centralisation of intangibles in an IP company

Ch.IX · ¶9.2 (3rd bullet), 9.57, 9.65–9.66, 9.68–9.70 · MNE Group · IP holding structure

inRange illustration, not an OECD example
At a glance
Local operating entities transfer their trademarks, know-how and customer contracts to a newly-created group IP company, which then licenses them back. How many distinct transactions need to be priced — and on what basis?
Operating subs A, B, C
Pre-restructuring owners of local trademarks, know-how, contracts
transfer of IP + ongoing concern
IPCo
Newly-created central IP holding entity
licence-back · royalty
Operating subs (post)
Now licensees of the centralised IP
  1. Group decision to centralise IP ownership in IPCo for management reasons (synergies, single-window licensing).
  2. Operating subs A, B, C assign their trademarks, know-how, and (in A's case) the customer contracts and key R&D staff to IPCo.
  3. IPCo licenses the IP back to the operating subs for a royalty; in A's case the relocation also moves an experienced workforce.
  4. Group must now price (a) what was transferred to IPCo and (b) the post-restructuring licence-back.
A

Sub A didn't just transfer trademarks — it also moved customer contracts and a key R&D team. Between independents this looks like the transfer of an integrated business unit.

Price item-by-item, or as a single ongoing concern?

Analysis · Ongoing-concern valuation
¶9.68–9.69. The transfer of an ongoing concern means the transfer of assets bundled with the ability to perform certain functions and assume certain risks. The arm's-length compensation does not necessarily amount to the sum of the separate valuations; aggregate valuation may give the most reliable measure. The valuation should reflect ALL the valuable elements that would be remunerated between independent parties, including the impact of the assembled workforce (cross-ref Section D.7 of Chapter I; Section A.4.6 of Chapter VI).
B

IPCo is a small holding company with limited substance. It now licenses the IP back to the operating subs.

Can IPCo just pick a market-range royalty, regardless of whether it actually controls the IP risks?

Analysis · Substance over legal title
¶9.57 directs the analyst to Chapter VI Sections D.1–D.4 for valuing intangibles transferred and licensed back. Legal ownership is the starting point, not the endpoint: under Chapter VI Section B.2, IPCo's return depends on whether it actually performs (or controls) the DEMPE functions and bears the associated risks. If it does not, the licence-back royalty cannot rest only on legal title.
Key takeaway
Centralising IP into a holding company is usually not one transaction but several — a transfer of value (often an ongoing concern, not isolated assets) plus a post-restructuring licence-back. Both must be priced at arm's length, and the licence-back can't outrun IPCo's substance.

Related: Chapter VI Sections B.2 (DEMPE), D.1–D.4 (IP valuation) · Section E.2 of Part I (transfer of intangibles) · Section A.4.6 of Chapter VI (ongoing concern) · Example 6 (transfer of ongoing concern)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →