Example 2 — Centralisation of intangibles in an IP company
Ch.IX · ¶9.2 (3rd bullet), 9.57, 9.65–9.66, 9.68–9.70 · MNE Group · IP holding structure
inRange illustration, not an OECD exampleThe parties
What happens
- Group decision to centralise IP ownership in IPCo for management reasons (synergies, single-window licensing).
- Operating subs A, B, C assign their trademarks, know-how, and (in A's case) the customer contracts and key R&D staff to IPCo.
- IPCo licenses the IP back to the operating subs for a royalty; in A's case the relocation also moves an experienced workforce.
- Group must now price (a) what was transferred to IPCo and (b) the post-restructuring licence-back.
The questions
Sub A didn't just transfer trademarks — it also moved customer contracts and a key R&D team. Between independents this looks like the transfer of an integrated business unit.
Price item-by-item, or as a single ongoing concern?
IPCo is a small holding company with limited substance. It now licenses the IP back to the operating subs.
Can IPCo just pick a market-range royalty, regardless of whether it actually controls the IP risks?
Related: Chapter VI Sections B.2 (DEMPE), D.1–D.4 (IP valuation) · Section E.2 of Part I (transfer of intangibles) · Section A.4.6 of Chapter VI (ongoing concern) · Example 6 (transfer of ongoing concern)