Example 10 — Distributor conversion: three profitability profiles
Ch.IX · ¶9.46–9.47 · Distributor · foreign principal
OECD Guidelines 2022The parties
The example shows the distributor's perspective only; the Guidelines state that the principal's perspective should also be taken into account.
What happens
- The starting point is a full-fledged distributor with a long-term contractual arrangement and five years of profitability data. In the set-up in ¶9.45, its rights under that contract give it the realistic option of accepting or refusing a conversion.
- Under the restructuring it would become a limited risk distributor acting for a foreign associated enterprise, the principal. The existing distribution arrangement is renegotiated, and the renegotiation reallocates risk between the parties.
- Profitability is projected on both footings: as a full-fledged distributor over the remaining term of the agreement, and as a limited risk distributor for the next three years.
- In all three scenarios the limited risk projection is 2% per year; the historical and full-fledged figures differ from one scenario to the next.
The questions
Scenario 1 of the Guidelines' table. As a full-fledged distributor, profitability in the last five years was -2%, 4%, 2%, 0% and 6%, and it is projected at -2% to 6% over the remaining term of the agreement, with significant uncertainties within that range. As a limited risk distributor, it is projected at 2% per year for the next three years.
Would an independent party be willing to give up this uncertain profit potential for a stable 2%?
Scenario 2 of the Guidelines' table. As a full-fledged distributor, profitability in the last five years was 5%, 10%, 5%, 5% and 10%, and it is projected at 5% to 10% over the remaining term of the agreement, with significant uncertainties within that range. As a limited risk distributor, it is projected at 2% per year for the next three years.
Would independent parties in the distributor's situation agree to the conversion for no additional compensation?
Scenario 3 of the Guidelines' table. As a full-fledged distributor, profitability in the last five years was 5%, 7%, 10%, 8% and 6%, but it is projected at only 0% to 4% over the remaining term of the agreement, with significant uncertainties within that range; the table puts this down to new competitive pressures. As a limited risk distributor, it is projected at 2% per year for the next three years.
What does this scenario show about assessing the profit potential the distributor gives up?
Related: Section D.2 of Part I (reallocation of risks and profit potential) · ¶9.45 (the conversion on which the three scenarios build) · Example 1 (full-fledged → limited-risk distributor)