Compensation for the restructuring itself

Example 11 — Pricing inventory transferred on conversion

Ch.IX · ¶9.49–9.53 · Taxpayer · foreign associated enterprise

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A full-fledged manufacturer and distributor becomes a toll manufacturer and limited risk distributor for a newly established foreign associated enterprise. At the changeover it still has raw materials and finished products on its balance sheet, and these are transferred to that enterprise. How is the arm's-length price of this inventory determined?
Taxpayer
Was a full-fledged manufacturer and distributor · now toll manufacturer and limited risk distributor
raw materials and finished products on hand
Foreign associated enterprise
Established as part of the restructuring · owns raw materials and finished products · assumes inventory risk

The Guidelines use this example solely to illustrate the valuation of inventory transfers.

  1. Before the restructuring, the taxpayer buys raw materials, manufactures finished products, performs marketing and distribution functions and sells to third-party customers, assuming risks such as inventory, bad debt and market risks.
  2. The restructuring involves setting up a foreign associated enterprise, which acquires intangibles from several affiliates, the taxpayer among them.
  3. Under the new model, the foreign associated enterprise acquires the raw materials and places them on consignment at the taxpayer's premises for manufacturing against a fee. The foreign associated enterprise owns the stock of finished products; the taxpayer buys them for immediate resale, only after it has made a sale to a customer.
  4. Inventory risk, previously borne by the taxpayer, is now assumed under the contract by the foreign associated enterprise, which both controls that risk and has the financial capacity to assume it.
  5. To move to the new arrangement, the taxpayer hands over to the foreign associated enterprise the raw materials and finished products then on its own balance sheet.

When the new arrangement starts, the taxpayer still has raw materials and finished products on its balance sheet, and these are transferred to the foreign associated enterprise. The taxpayer has manufactured the finished products, while the marketing and distribution functions for them still remain to be performed.

How is the arm's-length transfer price for the inventory determined?

OECD analysis · Three possibilities, none prescribed
The Guidelines do not choose a method: the choice depends on the comparability analysis of the parties, including a functional analysis that may have to cover a transition period. Three possibilities are mentioned, none ranked above the others: comparable uncontrolled prices for the raw materials and finished products, to the extent comparability is met; for the finished products, the price at which they are resold to customers, reduced by an arm's-length reward for the marketing and distribution functions that have yet to be performed; or manufacturing costs plus an arm's-length mark-up for the manufacturer's functions, assets and risks, although the market value of inventories is sometimes so low that no profit element can be added to costs. The choice depends in part on which side of the transaction, the manufacturing already done or the marketing and sales still to come, is simpler and can be evaluated with more certainty. The example is confined to inventory valuation: it does not delineate the restructuring as a whole or suggest that any one method is always acceptable.
Key takeaway
The arm's-length principle applies to inventory that passes between associated enterprises in different jurisdictions when a business model changes. Which approach fits depends on the comparability analysis and, in part, on which side of the transaction can be evaluated with more certainty.

Related: Section E.1 of Part I (tangible assets) · ¶3.18–3.19 (choice of the tested party) · Section D.1 of Chapter I (accurate delineation, which this example does not undertake)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →