Compensation for the restructuring itself
Example 12 — Customer contracts ended so an affiliate can step in
Ch.IX · ¶9.67 · Company A · Company B
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A voluntarily ends valuable long-term contracts with independent customers, in circumstances where the customers are bound, legally or commercially, to make similar arrangements with Company B, a foreign entity in the same MNE group. B now holds the contractual rights and their profit potential. Is there anything to price between A and B?
The parties
Company A
Held valuable long-term customer contracts · terminates them voluntarilycontracts terminated
Independent customers
Legally or commercially obligated to contract with Bsimilar contracts concluded
Company B
Foreign entity in the same MNE group as A · enters into similar contractsWhat happens
- A's long-term contracts with independent customers are valuable: they carry significant profit potential for A.
- Later, A ends these contracts by its own choice.
- The circumstances are such that the customers are obligated, legally or commercially, to make similar arrangements with B, a foreign entity belonging to the same MNE group as A.
- As a result, B now holds the contractual rights and the profit potential attached to them, which A held before.
Analysis
Assume the factual situation is that B could contract with the customers only if A gave up its own contractual rights in B's favour, and that A ended its contracts only in the knowledge that the customers were obligated, legally or commercially, to conclude similar arrangements with B.
How should the termination of A's contracts be analysed?
OECD analysis · Possible transfer of contractual rights
The Guidelines look at the substance. If that is the factual situation (B could obtain the contracts only if A gave up its rights, and A terminated only in the knowledge that the customers were obligated to contract with B), the arrangement is in substance a three-party (tri-partite) transaction. That may amount to A transferring valuable contractual rights to B, a transfer that may call for arm's-length remuneration. This depends on what the surrendered rights are worth, from A's perspective and from B's.
Key takeaway
A transfer of valuable contractual rights between associated enterprises can take place through third parties, without a direct transaction between the two. Where a company gives up a contract so that an affiliate can conclude a similar one, the substance may be a transfer of those rights, for which arm's-length remuneration may be due depending on their value to both sides.
Related: Section E.2.4 of Part I (contractual rights) · ¶9.66 (valuable contractual rights transferred or surrendered between associated enterprises)