Compensation for the restructuring itself

Example 13 — Outsourcing and the taxpayer's restructuring costs

Ch.IX · ¶9.74 · Taxpayer · associated enterprise

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A taxpayer that makes and sells products in a high-cost jurisdiction outsources manufacturing to an associated enterprise in a low-cost jurisdiction, buys the products from it and goes on selling them to third-party customers. The move may bring it restructuring costs. Would independent parties expect the associated enterprise to compensate it?
Taxpayer
High-cost jurisdiction · outsources manufacturing · continues to sell to third-party customers
manufacturing activity
Associated enterprise
Low-cost jurisdiction · manufactures the products and sells them to the taxpayer
  1. The taxpayer manufactures and sells products in a high-cost jurisdiction.
  2. The taxpayer decides that an associated enterprise in a low-cost jurisdiction will do the manufacturing instead (outsourcing).
  3. After the restructuring, the taxpayer buys the manufactured products from the associated enterprise and goes on selling them to third-party customers.
  4. The taxpayer may incur restructuring costs as a result, but it also stands to save on its future purchases compared with its own manufacturing costs.

The taxpayer restructures of its own accord, accepting the restructuring costs in return for the savings it anticipates. Assume that the benefits it anticipates are greater than its restructuring costs.

Would independent parties require the associated enterprise, as transferee, to compensate the taxpayer?

OECD analysis · Compensation not necessarily required
The Guidelines describe a party that voluntarily decides to restructure and to bear the related costs in exchange for anticipated savings. Here the taxpayer may incur restructuring costs, but the outsourcing also makes it possible for it to procure the products at a saving compared with its own manufacturing costs. Independent parties setting up this kind of outsourcing might not necessarily insist on explicit compensation from the transferee; the Guidelines give the example of a transferor whose anticipated benefits exceed its restructuring costs. This is not a rule that compensation is never due: it is an example of when it may not be required. A further issue is whether, and how, location savings are to be divided between the parties, which Section D.6 of Chapter I and Section E of Part II address.
Key takeaway
Restructuring costs borne by the transferor do not automatically call for explicit compensation from the transferee. Independent parties may not necessarily require it where a party restructures voluntarily in exchange for anticipated savings, for example where its anticipated benefits are greater than those costs.

Related: Section E.4 of Part I (outsourcing) · Section D.6 of Chapter I and Section E of Part II (allocation of location savings)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →