Compensation for the restructuring itself
Example 14 — Terminated manufacturer: who bears the indemnification?
Ch.IX · ¶9.93–9.97 · Entity A · Entity B · Entity C
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Entity A terminates its manufacturing contract with entity B, an associated manufacturer, and has entity C, another associated manufacturer, carry on the work. It is established that, at arm's length, B could claim an indemnification for the detriment this causes it. Which party should ultimately bear it: A, C or another group member?
The parties
Entity A
Terminates the manufacturing contract with B · turns to Ccontract terminated
Entity B
Associated manufacturer · contract terminated · could claim an indemnificationmanufacturing taken over
Entity C
Another associated manufacturer · continues the manufacturingWhat happens
- Entity A and entity B, two associated enterprises, have a manufacturing contract; B is the manufacturer.
- A terminates the contract.
- A chooses entity C, another associated manufacturer, to carry on the manufacturing that B used to perform.
- It is established, on the guidance in Section F, that at arm's length and on the facts of the case B could claim an indemnification for the detriment the termination causes it.
Analysis
B's claim to an indemnification is taken as established in this example; the Guidelines recall that it cannot be presumed for every termination. A terminated the contract, C takes over the manufacturing, and other members of the MNE group may also benefit from the restructuring.
Which party should, in the end, bear the cost of indemnifying B?
OECD analysis · No single answer
No single answer holds for every case: the response rests on the facts and circumstances (¶9.93), and the Guidelines go on to describe situations that can arise. A might be willing to bear the cost at arm's length, for instance if it expects cost savings from its new manufacturing agreement with C whose present value is greater than the indemnification (¶9.95). C might be prepared to pay an up-front fee to get the manufacturing contract rights from A if the present value of its expected profits makes the investment worthwhile; that payment might go to A, or take the form of C settling what A owes B (a constructive payment to A), and C might also pay B, for example for the transfer of certain rights that B had (¶9.96). A and C might be willing to share the cost, and where the benefits of the restructuring accrue to another group member, that member may bear it, directly or indirectly (¶9.97). The analysis starts from accurate delineation of the actual transactions that make up the restructuring, including economically related transactions with other group enterprises.
Key takeaway
The party that terminates a contract is not automatically the party that bears the indemnification: the terminating party, the party taking over the activity, both of them or another group member may bear it at arm's length. Which of them does depends on the facts and circumstances, in particular the parties' rights and other assets, the risks they assume, the economic rationale for the termination, who is expected to benefit from it and the options realistically available to them (¶9.93).
Related: Section F.3 of Part I (which party should ultimately bear the costs of the indemnification) · ¶9.78 (no presumption of a right to indemnification; see Example 5) · ¶1.36–1.38 (delineating the controlled transaction, including economically related transactions)