Post-restructuring TP & location savings

Example 15 — Brand ownership moved to a newly set up affiliate

Ch.IX · ¶9.122–9.124 · Company A · Company Z

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A owns an MNE's brand intangibles, and 125 employees at its head office run the worldwide marketing strategy. A newly set up affiliate, Company Z, then acquires legal ownership of the intangibles for a lump sum; A is paid on a cost plus basis from then on and the remaining profits go to Z. What is the arrangement in substance?
Company A
Country A · head office with 125 marketing-strategy employees · cost plus after the restructuring
legal ownership of the brand intangibles
Company Z
Country Z · newly set up · managed by a local trust company · receives the remaining profits

Affiliates manufacture the products under contract for Company A and affiliates distribute them; their remuneration stays the same after the restructuring.

  1. An MNE's products owe their value to consumer recognition of the brand, not to their technical features. Company A in Country A owns the trademarks, trade names and other intangibles represented by the brand and assumes the risks of their ownership, development and exploitation.
  2. Developing, maintaining and executing a worldwide marketing strategy are the MNE's main value drivers. This work is done by 125 employees at Company A's head office, which also provides central services to group affiliates.
  3. Affiliates manufacture the products under contract for Company A, and affiliates that buy them from Company A distribute them. What Company A has left after their arm's-length remuneration is regarded as rewarding its intangibles, marketing activities and central services.
  4. Company A then transfers legal ownership of the brand intangibles to Company Z, an affiliate newly set up in Country Z, and receives a lump sum payment in return.
  5. From then on, Company A's services to Company Z and to the rest of the group are paid for on a cost plus basis. Nothing changes in the remuneration of the contract manufacturers and distributors, and Company Z receives the profits that remain.

A local trust company manages Company Z. Company Z has no employees or directors with the capability to perform control functions over the risks of owning or strategically developing the brand intangibles, it does not in fact perform such functions, and it lacks the financial capacity to assume those risks. The same Company A employees still develop, maintain and execute the marketing strategy, and once a year senior Company A officials travel to Country Z to formally validate strategic decisions prepared by the head office in Country A; both activities are remunerated at cost plus.

What may accurate delineation show the post-restructuring arrangement to be?

OECD analysis · May be a funding arrangement
On these findings Company A's functions and risks are the same after the restructuring as before: it has the capability to perform control functions over the risk of exploiting the intangibles and actually performs them, and it still develops, maintains and executes the worldwide marketing strategy. Company Z, by contrast, is not capable of performing control functions and does not perform the ones needed to assume the intangible-related risks. Accurate delineation may therefore show that what the parties have is in substance a funding arrangement between Company A and Company Z, not a restructuring that centralises intangible management. The commercial rationality of the transaction may also need to be assessed under Section D.2 of Chapter I, on the full facts and circumstances. Both steps are put as possibilities ("may"), and the example does not say what return either company should earn.
Key takeaway
After a restructuring, what each party earns should match the functions it actually performs, the assets it uses and the risks it assumes (¶9.121); a transfer of legal ownership does not settle it. Where the transferor carries on exactly as before and the transferee can neither control nor financially bear the risks, the arrangement may in substance be a funding arrangement.

Related: Section D of Part II (comparing the pre- and post-restructuring situations); ¶9.121 states the principle this example illustrates · Section D.2 of Chapter I (recognition of the accurately delineated transaction; commercial rationality) · ¶6.23 (meaning of the term "brand")

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →