Post-restructuring TP & location savings

Example 16 — Location savings in subcontracted engineering services

Ch.IX · ¶9.130–9.131 · Company X · Company Y

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
An enterprise in Country X, where engineers' wages are high, subcontracts much of its engineering work to a new Country Y subsidiary, which hires equally qualified engineers for substantially lower wages. Competitive pressures later force its hourly rate down, passing part of the savings on to clients. Which party should be attributed the rest?
Company Y
New subsidiary in Country Y · equally qualified engineers at substantially lower wages
subcontracted engineering work
Company X
Enterprise in Country X · well known · deals directly with the clients
engineering services
Independent clients
Charged an hourly rate · not necessarily aware of the subcontracting
  1. Company X, an enterprise in Country X where wages for qualified engineers are high, provides highly specialised, high-quality engineering services to independent clients at a fixed hourly rate comparable to what competitors charge for similar services in the same market.
  2. A large part of Company X's engineering work is then subcontracted to Company Y, a new subsidiary in Country Y, which hires equally qualified engineers for substantially lower wages; significant location savings arise for the group.
  3. The clients still deal directly with Company X; they do not necessarily know about the subcontracting. For a while, Company X is able to keep its hourly rate at the original level.
  4. Competitive pressures then force Company X to lower its hourly rate to a level that would not cover the wages of qualified engineers in Country X but still yields a benefit when the engineers are in Country Y. Clients thereby receive part of the location savings.

Demand for this type of engineering service is high. Company Y is the only company in a lower-cost location able to provide the services to the required quality standard, and its established technical know-how is a barrier to competition that lets it withstand competitive pricing pressures. Company X cannot engage qualified engineers in Country X for this work, because their wages would cost too much relative to the hourly rate charged to clients.

Who should be attributed the location savings that stay within the group?

OECD analysis · Savings factored into Y's remuneration
The answer depends on the functions, risks and assets of the parties and on the options realistically available to each of them. On the assumed facts Company X does not have many options other than using Company Y: Y is the only provider in a lower-cost location that meets the quality standard, its technical know-how is a barrier to competition, and engineers in Country X would cost too much for the hourly rate charged to clients. The Guidelines conclude that the location savings Company Y created should be taken into account in what Company X pays it, on top of the value of Y's services, which includes any intangibles used to provide them. They do not say in what proportions the savings are to be shared, and they add that in some instances the contributions of the two companies may meet the criteria for using a transactional profit split method.
Key takeaway
Attributing location savings means looking at each party's functions, risks and assets and at the options realistically available to it. Where the enterprise that subcontracts the work has few alternatives to a lower-cost service provider with established know-how, the provider's remuneration should take into account the location savings it creates.

Related: Section E of Part II (location savings) · Section D.6 of Chapter I (location savings and other local market features) · Example 8 (the clothing example of ¶9.128–9.129)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →