Post-restructuring TP & location savings

Example 17 — An acquired enterprise's earlier dealings with the group

Ch.IX · ¶9.110 · MNE group · acquired enterprise

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
An enterprise that used to deal with an MNE group as an independent party is acquired, so its transactions with the group are now controlled. After the acquisition those transactions are restructured. Can the conditions agreed before the acquisition help to price the controlled transactions after it?
Acquired enterprise
Formerly an independent counterparty of the MNE group · now an associated enterprise
transactions: uncontrolled before, controlled after
MNE group
Deals with the enterprise before and after the acquisition

The Guidelines do not say what the transactions are or in which direction they run.

  1. An enterprise deals with an MNE group as an independent party.
  2. The enterprise is acquired; its transactions with the group are now controlled transactions.
  3. After the acquisition, those now controlled transactions are restructured.

Before the acquisition the two sides dealt with each other as independent parties, so those earlier transactions were uncontrolled. They took place at a different time from the controlled transactions now to be priced. Suppose the restructuring has also changed the conditions, so that, for instance, the bad debt risk is now assumed by a different party.

Can the pre-acquisition transactions be used to price the controlled transactions after the acquisition?

OECD analysis · Possible CUP, subject to review
The Guidelines offer this as a case in which the CUP method could possibly be applied. Because the enterprise dealt with the group independently before it was acquired, the conditions of those uncontrolled transactions might provide a CUP for the controlled transactions that follow, but only after the five economically relevant characteristics (the comparability factors) have been reviewed, together with the possible effect of the two sets of transactions taking place at different times. Where the restructuring has changed the conditions, an adjustment for the functions, assets and/or risks transferred might still be feasible if the facts and circumstances allow it; the paragraph's own illustration is a comparability adjustment to reflect that the bad debt risk is assumed by a different party. The objection to before-and-after comparisons in ¶9.118 concerns earlier controlled transactions; here the earlier transactions were uncontrolled (¶9.125). Every step is put as a possibility: ¶9.110 does not say that the earlier transactions will in fact be reliable comparables.
Key takeaway
When a former independent counterparty is acquired, its earlier dealings with the group were uncontrolled and may offer a comparable for the controlled transactions that follow. They are a candidate, not a given: the comparability factors and the effect of the difference in timing have to be reviewed, and it may be possible, depending on the facts, to adjust for what the restructuring changed.

Related: Section B of Part II (selecting and applying a method for the post-restructuring controlled transactions) · ¶9.125 (refers back to this example: before-and-after comparisons can be made where the earlier transactions were not controlled and adjustments can reliably be made; whether they are reliable comparables is evaluated under ¶3.2)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →