Benefit test

Example 9 — Marketing scope & duplication

Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 9 · ¶34–39 · Apparel MNE

OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)
At a glance
Company A and Company B both work on the marketing for a new product launch. When does that overlap count as duplication, and when is it really two different activities? Three scenarios test the line — by content, by geography, and by scope.
Company A (Country A)
Market research / verification
marketing activities
Company B (Country B)
Worldwide distributor; designs launch and campaign
  1. MNE Group designs a new line of menswear for the 25–45 demographic.
  2. Company A in Country A performs market research connected to the launch.
  3. Company B in Country B is the worldwide distributor and runs the launch campaign.
A

Company A researches potential brand ambassadors. Company B designs the launch campaign and decides distribution and retail marketing.

Does this overlap count as duplication?

OECD analysis · No duplication
There is no duplication because the marketing activities performed by Company A for Company B differ from those undertaken by Company B itself in relation to the same products.
B

Company A finds ambassadors for markets outside Country B; Company B (the worldwide distributor) finds ambassadors for Country B itself. Cultural and linguistic differences mean ambassadors from one market don't work in another.

Is Company A's research duplicative of Company B's local ambassador work?

OECD analysis · Service rendered
The market research by Company A is not duplicative of Company B's, because they have different geographic scopes. This enables Company B to customise the campaign by region. Company B obtains commercial value from Company A's activities, which satisfy the benefit test and constitute an intra-group service.
C

Company B designs the global campaign. It outsources to Company A two things only: checking compliance with local laws and customs, and translating into local languages. Company A doesn't design any of the campaign itself.

Are the two roles duplicative because they relate to the same campaign?

OECD analysis · No duplication
Although both companies perform activities related to the global marketing campaign, the mere fact that the activities relate to the same overall initiative does not lead to the conclusion that they are duplicative. The activities undertaken by Company A are separate and distinct from those of Company B.
Key takeaway
Duplication is tested on what is actually being done — by content, geography, and scope. Overlap with another affiliate's general initiative is not duplication if the specific activities differ.

Related: Section B.2 (duplication) · Example 3 (in-house capability)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →