Benefit test
Example 10 — Passive association (supplier discount)
Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 10 · ¶40–42
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
An independent supplier offers Company A a discounted price not because group members did anything, but because the supplier hopes to win future business from other group members. Is the discount the result of an intra-group service?
The parties
Supplier
Independent · offers €8/unit instead of €10discounted price
Company A
Manufacturer · receives discount(group affiliation)
Wider MNE group
Passive association · no concerted actionWhat happens
- Independent Supplier would normally charge Company A €10/unit based on its standalone profile.
- Supplier expects long-term business with other group members and aims to be their main supplier.
- Supplier offers Company A a reduced €8/unit even though Company A is not placing larger orders.
- No group member performs any activity to produce the discount.
Analysis
Company A gets the discount purely because it's part of a larger group — no group member actually did anything to obtain it.
Is this an intra-group service to Company A?
OECD analysis · No intra-group service
The price reduction is attributable solely to Company A being part of a larger MNE group — passive association — and not to deliberate concerted action of group members or the performance of any service or other function. The supplier's unilateral decision is not a relevant activity for the benefit test. There is no intra-group service transaction.
Key takeaway
Benefits arising purely from membership of an MNE group — passive association — do not give rise to an intra-group service. Look for an activity performed by a group member; the benefit must be tied to that activity.
Related: Section B.2 (passive association) · Chapter X · Section D (group synergies)