Benefit test
Example 23 — IT support despite a cheaper alternative
Draft (June 2026) · Main text · ¶7.20 · Parent Co · Company B
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
Company B, located in Country B, receives certain IT support services from its affiliate in Country A, Parent Co. Company B could have done the work in-house or bought it from local independent providers at lower cost. Does the cheaper alternative mean that the benefit test is not met?
The parties
Parent Co (Country A)
Performs IT support servicesIT support services
Company B (Country B)
Affiliate · recipient · cheaper options availableWhat happens
- Parent Co and Company B are affiliates, located in Country A and Country B respectively.
- Company B receives certain IT support services, which Parent Co performs.
- Company B was in a position to carry out these activities in-house or to buy them from local independent providers at lower cost.
Analysis
The accurate delineation of the transaction indicates that Company B, had it been an independent enterprise in comparable circumstances, would have been willing to pay for the activities. It could, however, have done the work in-house or bought it from local independent providers at lower cost.
Does the cheaper alternative mean that the benefit test is not met?
OECD analysis · Benefit test met
The draft concludes that Company B obtains a benefit from Parent Co's activities, since as an independent enterprise in comparable circumstances it would have been willing to pay for them. Whether the benefit test is met does not turn on whether the provider's cost is higher or lower than the cost of buying the service from an independent provider, nor on whether the recipient had the resources and the capacity to do the work itself for less. It turns on whether the activity gives the recipient economic or commercial value that enhances or maintains its business position. What Company B should pay is a separate question of arm's-length pricing, which the example does not answer.
Key takeaway
The benefit test asks whether an activity gives the recipient economic or commercial value, not whether the recipient could have obtained it for less. Whether the charge is arm's length is a separate analysis that should not be conflated with the benefit test.
Related: Section B.1.3 (the benefit test and the arm's-length remuneration) · Section C.2.1 (selection of the most appropriate transfer pricing method) · Annex I, Example 3 (accounting and legal alongside in-house staff)