Shareholder activity
Example 5 — Management information system
Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 5 · ¶21–23
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
Company A (the parent) runs a management information system fed by data from all group entities. Part of what it produces is consolidation for Company A's own reporting. Part is operational advice to subsidiaries. Is this one charge, two, or neither?
The parties
Company A
Parent · operates the MISdata ↑ · advice ↓
Subsidiaries
Provide data; receive recommendationsWhat happens
- Company A operates an MIS that collects financial and operational data from all group entities.
- The MIS supports Company A's own budgeting, performance control, and consolidated financial statements.
- Based on the data, Company A issues quarterly operational recommendations — e.g. reallocate capital from underperforming lines to higher-growth segments.
Analysis
Two things come out of the same system: parent-level consolidation that Company A has to do anyway, and operational advice that subsidiaries actually use to run their business.
Service, shareholder activity, or a mix?
OECD analysis · Mixed — partial service
Activities performed solely because of Company A's ownership interest — such as consolidation for parent-level reporting — are shareholder activities and do not give rise to a service. However, where recommendations strengthen subsidiaries' financial performance and operations (e.g. capital reallocation advice), the benefit test may be met and a service rendered. A fee may be charged for that portion.
Key takeaway
The same system can produce both shareholder activity and intra-group services. Bifurcate by reference to who benefits: parent-only reporting is shareholder; advice that subsidiaries would have paid for is a service.
Related: Section B.1 (shareholder activities) · Example 6 (divestment as shareholder activity)