Benefit test
Example 3 — Accounting & legal alongside in-house staff
Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 3 · ¶16–17
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
Company B pays Company A for accounting and legal support. Company B also employs its own accountants and lawyers — but their work is different from what Company A provides.
The parties
Company A
Accounting & legal supportservices
Company B
Pays Company A+ in-house accounting & legal staff
What happens
- Company A performs certain accounting and legal activities.
- Company B pays Company A for those activities.
- Company B's own accounting and legal personnel perform different work from what Company A provides.
Analysis
The question is whether having in-house accountants and lawyers means Company B can't be receiving a service from Company A.
Is Company A's work still a service to Company B?
OECD analysis · Service rendered
The benefit test asks whether an independent enterprise in comparable circumstances would be willing to pay for the activity or perform it itself. The mere fact that Company B has internal capability does not preclude recognition of a service for the activity performed by Company A.
Key takeaway
Having in-house capability is not the same as performing the same activity. Look at what the provider actually does; if it differs from what the recipient does internally, an intra-group service can still arise.
Related: Section B.2 (duplication) · Example 9 (geographic / functional duplication)