Benefit test

Example 2 — Centralised marketing

Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 2 · ¶10–15 · Hotel Group

OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)
At a glance
A central marketing team in Country A serves group hotels in Countries A and B through a new corporate-clients unit. Is it still a service when revenue grows as expected? When competition wipes the growth out? When an unrelated country grows for reasons of its own?
Company A (Country A)
Marketing & sales · corporate-clients unit
services
Company B (Country B)
Hotel operator
Company C (Country C)
Hotel operator (no service activity)

The corporate-clients unit serves Country A and B only. Country C's hotels are not targeted by its activities.

  1. Hotel Group sets a five-year target to grow corporate-client share in Countries A and B (30–45% incremental revenue).
  2. Company A creates a corporate-clients unit inside the central marketing team.
  3. The unit prospects clients, designs packages, runs digital campaigns, bids on global tenders and joins B2B platforms.
  4. Company A continually reviews its plans against evolving market conditions.
A

A year in, hotels in Countries A and B are winning more corporate clients — on track to hit the five-year target.

Are the unit's activities an intra-group service to the Country A and B hotels?

OECD analysis · Service rendered
The activities performed by the corporate-clients unit constitute intra-group services to hotels in Countries A and B because they provide economic or commercial value for which independent enterprises in comparable circumstances would be willing to pay or perform for themselves.
B

New competing hotel chains undercut Country B prices. By year five, Country B growth is only 10% — well below the 30–45% target.

Does missing the target mean no service was rendered to Company B?

OECD analysis · Service rendered
A service is considered to be provided to Company B even though revenue growth has not materialised as expected. The shortfall reflects competitive market conditions, not absence of activity by Company A. The benefit test is judged ex ante.
C

Country C hotels also see sales rise — but driven by tourism, infrastructure and film shoots. The corporate-clients unit does nothing aimed at Country C.

Does Country C's growth count as a service from Company A?

OECD analysis · No service to Company C
The increase in profitability of Company C cannot be attributed to the new corporate-clients unit, since the unit performs no activities for Country C. The uplift is caused by exogenous factors and the activities of Company A are not a service rendered to Company C.
Key takeaway
Service recognition turns on what was performed and reasonably expected to benefit the recipient — not on whether the recipient's revenue ultimately rose or fell. Benefits enjoyed for unrelated, exogenous reasons are not services from the provider.

Related: Section B.2 (benefit test) · Example 1 (later adverse event)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →