Benefit test
Example 1 — Cybersecurity services
Draft (June 2026) · Annex I · Example 1 · ¶1–9 · Retailer Group
OECD discussion draft, June 2026 (not final)At a glance
A retailer's central IT function commissions and implements a group-wide cybersecurity programme. Does that still count as an intra-group service if a breach later occurs? What if a recipient is loss-making?
The parties
Company A
Central IT servicesservices
Group entities
Online retail subsidiariesPlus: external cybersecurity vendor engaged by Company A — not a party to the intra-group charge.
What happens
- Retailer Group pivots from physical stores to online; cyber risk increases.
- Company A engages an external vendor to assess group-wide digital security.
- Company A reviews recommendations and implements enhanced security systems.
- Company A charges subsidiaries an arm's-length amount for the assessment and implementation.
The questions
A
Two years on, several group entities suffer a cyberattack and lose business. The breach wasn't Company A's fault — its work was sound.
Was an intra-group service still rendered?
OECD analysis · Service rendered
When Company A performed the assessment, there was a reasonable expectation that group entities would benefit by minimising the risk of a breach. The subsequent breach does not negate the service, since the damage was not caused by inadequate performance by Company A.
B
Company B, one recipient of the cybersecurity services, has been loss-making throughout the audit years.
Does Company B's losses mean no service was rendered to it?
OECD analysis · Service rendered
The mere fact that Company B has been operating at a loss does not provide grounds to conclude that no intra-group service was rendered. The benefit test is judged ex ante, not by reference to the recipient's ex-post profitability.
Key takeaway
The benefit test is judged ex ante. Neither a later adverse event nor the recipient's loss position negates an intra-group service that was reasonably expected to provide value at the time it was rendered.
Related: Section B.2 (benefit test) · Example 2 (revenue outcome)