Funding contributions & risk

Example 6 — Cash-box funder of intangible development

Annex I · Example 6 · ¶14–15

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A funds a five-year intangible development programme run entirely by Company B. Company A becomes the legal owner and expects USD 200m/year of residual profit. The Country B tax administration sees only a funder. What is Company A actually entitled to?
Company A
Funder · legal owner · controls financial risk
USD 100m/yr funding ↑ · contingent payments ↓
Company B
Performs and controls all DEMPE · existing IP and R&D track record
  1. Year 1: Companies A and B decide to develop an intangible building on Company B's track record.
  2. Five-year development phase; Company A funds USD 100m/yr; Company B performs and controls all DEMPE.
  3. Once developed, the intangible is expected to earn USD 550m/yr for ten years.
  4. Under the agreement, Company B licenses the intangible from Company A; contingent payments are calibrated to leave Company B with USD 200m/yr and Company A with USD 350m/yr.
  5. On audit, the Country B authority delineates the actual transaction.

Company A's only contribution is funding. It does have the money to bear the financial risk and actively controls that risk. Company B does all the actual R&D work and controls those risks.

What return does Company A deserve?

OECD analysis · Risk-adjusted funding return
Company A's contribution is solely funding. Taking into account its contributions and the realistic alternatives, Company A's anticipated remuneration is a risk-adjusted return on its funding commitment — illustratively USD 110m/yr, an 11% return. Company B is entitled to all remaining anticipated income, USD 440m/yr, rather than USD 200m as claimed. The taxpayer had incorrectly chosen Company B, not Company A, as the tested party.
Key takeaway
A funder who controls financial risk earns a risk-adjusted financial return — not the full residual that legal ownership might suggest. The DEMPE-performing party keeps the rest.

Related: Section B.2.1 (funding and control of financial risk) · Example 16 (no control of risk → risk-free return)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →