Funding contributions & risk

Example 16 — Funder without control — risk-free only

Annex I · Example 16 · ¶54–58 · Shuyona group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Shuyona sells all its IP to a new Country Z subsidiary, Company T. Company T becomes the contract manufacturer and signs contract-research agreements with Shuyona and Company S — but it has no technical staff, no ability to manage R&D, and no control over R&D risk. What return does Company T get?
Shuyona
Parent · designs and controls R&D programme
IP sale + contract R&D
Company T
Buyer of IP · manufacturer · no R&D capability
directed R&D
Company S
Subsidiary R&D centre · supervised by Shuyona
  1. Shuyona sells all technology-related patents and intangibles, including rights for ongoing research, to Company T in Country Z.
  2. Company T establishes a manufacturing plant in Country Z and supplies products to the group.
  3. Company T signs contract-research agreements with Shuyona and Company S, contractually bearing financial risk and paying cost-plus.
  4. Shuyona continues to design and supervise all R&D; Company T has no technical personnel.
  5. Company T contractually assumes the financial risk and has the financial capacity to do so, but does not exercise control over that risk.

Shuyona and Company S do all the R&D and manage the risks; Shuyona is in control. Company T has the money to absorb the financial risk, but doesn't actually steer it.

What return does Company T deserve?

OECD analysis · Risk-free funding return
The transaction should be accurately delineated as the provision of financing by Company T equating to the costs of the acquired intangibles and the ongoing development. Because Company T does not exercise control over the financial risk in accordance with paragraphs 6.63–6.64, it is entitled — in addition to its manufacturing reward — to no more than a risk-free return for its funding activities.
Key takeaway
Contractual risk-bearing plus financial capacity is not enough. Without the capacity to exercise control over the financial risk, a funder gets only a risk-free return — not the upside that legal ownership might imply.

Related: Section B.2.1 (funding and risk control) · Example 6 (with control → risk-adjusted return) · Example 17 (financing-return variant)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →