Legal vs. economic ownership
Example 5 — Same substance, but the value falls
Annex I · Example 5 · ¶13 · Premiere group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same setup as Example 4 — Company S has real decision-making capability — but the patents lose value during its ownership because of unanticipated external circumstances. Who takes the loss?
The parties
Premiere
Developer · sold patents at arm's-length pricedisposal proceeds (lower than purchase)
Company S
Active owner · runs the portfolio · sells at a lossWhat happens
- Premiere develops the patents and sells them to Company S at an arm's-length price.
- Company S runs the licensing programme using its own decision-making.
- External circumstances unanticipated at the time of transfer push the value down.
- Company S sells the patents at a loss.
Analysis
Company S runs the sale itself. The price fall was not foreseeable when it bought the patents.
Who absorbs the loss?
OECD analysis · Company S takes loss
Company S is entitled to retain the proceeds of the sale, meaning that it will suffer the loss. The same substance that would have entitled it to upside (Example 4) carries the downside here.
Key takeaway
Ownership is symmetric: substance that captures unexpected gains also bears unexpected losses. Risk allocation is judged ex ante and held to the entity that actually controls it.
Related: Example 4 (upside mirror image)