Legal vs. economic ownership

Example 4 — When the affiliate has real substance

Annex I · Example 4 · ¶10–12 · Premiere group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same R&D backdrop as Example 3 — but now Company S has employees who actually decide to take on the patents, run the licensing programme and monitor licensees. The price Company S paid was arm's-length. The patents then appreciate due to unforeseen events and Company S sells them at a gain. Who keeps the gain?
Premiere
Develops patents · transfers to Company S at arm's-length price
patent rights · arm's-length price ↑
Company S
Active decision-makers · runs licensing programme · manages disposal
  1. Premiere develops the patents and transfers them to Company S for an arm's-length price reflecting the parties' expectations at the time.
  2. Company S's own employees decide to take on the portfolio and run the licensing programme.
  3. Company S licenses the patents for several years.
  4. External circumstances unforeseen at the date of transfer push the patents' value up significantly.
  5. Company S decides, negotiates, and executes the sale of the patents to an unrelated buyer at a gain.

This time Company S has real substance — its own people, decisions, and the ability to control the risks. Assume the hard-to-value intangible rules don't apply.

Who keeps the gain on sale?

OECD analysis · Company S retains gain
Company S has people who actually take and execute the licensing and disposal decisions, monitor licensees, and manage the disposition. Under these circumstances, Company S is entitled to retain the proceeds of the sale, including amounts attributable to appreciation resulting from the unanticipated external circumstances.
Key takeaway
When the legal owner also has the people, decision-making and risk-control capability of an owner, it is entitled to the corresponding returns — including unanticipated upside. Substance unlocks ownership economics.

Related: Examples 1–3 (no substance at the title-holder) · Example 5 (downside variant)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →