Legal vs. economic ownership
Example 3 — Sale of patents after a period of licensing
Annex I · Example 3 · ¶8–9 · Premiere group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Facts as in Example 2. After a few years of licensing, Company S sells the patents to an independent buyer for a price reflecting appreciation since acquisition. Who gets the disposal proceeds?
The parties
Premiere
Performs and controls DEMPE throughoutdisposal proceeds
Company S
Registered owner · sells under Premiere's directionWhat happens
- Premiere is the parent and performs all R&D; its affiliate Company S (three patent lawyers, no R&D capability) is the registered owner of the resulting patents.
- Company S licenses the patents to associated and independent enterprises for several years.
- Acting under Premiere's direction, Company S sells the patents to an independent buyer.
- The sale price reflects appreciation in value during the licensing period.
Analysis
Company S still only handles patent registration. Premiere decided to sell and structured the deal.
Should Company S share in the gain when the patents are sold?
OECD analysis · Patent admin only
Company S's income should be the same as in Example 2 — compensation for its registration functions. It should not share in returns from exploitation of the intangibles, including returns generated from their disposition. Premiere, which controls DEMPE, captures the appreciation.
Key takeaway
Disposal gains follow the DEMPE party, not the title-holder. Registration plus contractual signing authority does not, by itself, generate a residual return.
Related: Examples 1, 2 (related fact pattern) · Examples 4, 5 (compare: where Company S has substance)