Legal vs. economic ownership
Example 2 — Company S licenses the patents to third parties
Annex I · Example 2 · ¶5–7 · Premiere group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same setup as Example 1, but now Company S — still just three patent lawyers — actually licenses the patents to associated and independent enterprises at arm's-length royalties. Does the royalty income belong to Company S?
The parties
Premiere
Parent · performs and controls all DEMPEroyalty income
Company S
Patent registrant · licenses patents under Premiere's directionWhat happens
- Premiere performs all R&D and controls the licensing strategy.
- Company S, the registered patent owner, licenses patents to associated and independent enterprises under Premiere's direction.
- Royalties flow to Company S; its three employees do not control or participate in the licensing decisions.
Analysis
Company S holds legal title but only registers and maintains the patents. Premiere still runs everything else — R&D, licensing strategy, decisions.
How much of the royalty income should Company S keep?
OECD analysis · Patent admin only
Based on the functions performed, assets used and risks assumed, Company S is entitled only to compensation for its patent registration functions and should not retain income above an arm's-length fee for those services. The true nature of the arrangement is a patent administration service contract; the amount Company S pays Premiere for the assignments should leave it with that arm's-length return only.
Key takeaway
Real licensing income does not automatically belong to the registered owner. Where the owner does not perform or control DEMPE, the arm's-length result strips out a service-level return and reallocates the rest to the DEMPE party.
Related: Example 1 (perpetual licence back) · Example 3 (sale to a third party)