Legal vs. economic ownership
Example 1 — Patent assignment to a low-functionality affiliate
Annex I · Example 1 · ¶1–4 · Premiere group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Premiere does all the R&D, but assigns each resulting patent to Company S — three lawyers, no R&D capability — for a nominal EUR 100. Company S immediately grants Premiere a perpetual, royalty-free, exclusive licence back. What is the real transaction, and how should it be priced?
The parties
Premiere
Parent · funds and performs all R&D · controls licensingnominal assignment ↑ · exclusive licence back ↓
Company S
Patent admin only · 3 lawyers · no R&DWhat happens
- Premiere funds and performs ongoing R&D in support of its business.
- When R&D produces a patentable invention, rights are assigned to Company S for a nominal EUR 100.
- As a condition of the assignment, Company S grants Premiere a perpetual, royalty-free, exclusive licence with sub-licence rights.
- Company S registers and maintains the patents but does not control or fund R&D; key decisions sit with Premiere management.
Analysis
Premiere does all the R&D — funding, decisions, risk. Company S's three lawyers just register the patents.
What is the real transaction here — a transfer of patents, or a service?
OECD analysis · Patent admin service
Looking at the actual conduct, the assignment plus the simultaneous licence-back in substance form a patent administration service arrangement. An arm's-length fee is determined for those administration services; Premiere — which performs all DEMPE functions, uses the assets and bears the risks — retains the bulk of the returns from exploiting the patents.
Key takeaway
Legal title to an intangible does not, by itself, entitle a party to the returns from it. Where the title-holder performs only administration, delineate the actual transaction as a service and leave the residual with the party doing the DEMPE.
Related: Section B (legal ownership) · Examples 2, 3 (same fact pattern, different exit paths)