Use of intangibles in sales and services (main text)
Example 32 — Patents used to make cars sold to associated distributors
Chapter VI · main text · ¶6.105 · Car manufacturer · associated distributors
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
A car manufacturer sells its cars to associated distributors. The cars are built using the manufacturer's valuable proprietary patents, which add significantly to their value, but the distributors acquire no right in those patents. Do the patents matter when the car sales are priced and, if so, at which points in the analysis?
The parties
Car manufacturer
Uses valuable proprietary patents · makes the carssale of cars
Associated distributors
Buy the cars · acquire no right in the patentsWhat happens
- A car manufacturer builds its cars using valuable proprietary patents.
- The patents make a significant contribution to the value of the cars.
- The manufacturer sells the cars to associated distributors.
- In buying the cars, the distributors obtain no right in the manufacturer's patents.
Analysis
The controlled transaction is the sale of cars. The patents are used to make the cars and add significantly to their value, yet the distributors obtain no right in them.
How should the manufacturer's patents be treated in the transfer pricing analysis of the car sales?
OECD analysis · Used, not transferred
An intangible can play a part in a controlled transaction even though neither it nor any right in it changes hands (¶6.104). Here an analysis of the car sales should identify the patents and the value they add, and take both into account at three points: when comparability is analysed, when the most appropriate method is selected and when the tested party is chosen. The distributors acquire no right in the patents, so there is no transfer: the patents are an input to manufacturing that may affect the value of the cars.
Key takeaway
An intangible used to make goods may affect their value without being transferred with them. It should still be identified and taken into account when comparability is analysed, the method is chosen and the tested party is selected.
Related: Section C.2 (use of intangibles in sales of goods or performance of services) · ¶6.106 (the same point for services) · Sections D.1 and D.5 (supplemental guidance; ¶6.104 cites the latter as D.4, but in the 2022 edition it is Section D.5, ¶6.196–6.212)